Im so confused right now. Im trying to figure out why surf was whacked. and there have some interesting points brought up since then. im at work and its hard to read this thread. i am going on lunch in an hour and we go back and read everything and make my ote then.
well the only thing surf did was vote for scrog. i dont know whether thats cause scrog is mafia and since he voted for him they whacked him thinking he might be the inspector, or if its because the mafia just wanted fingers pointed at scrog.
i dont want to vote for scrog cause i want to see a runoff. and after reviewing the other votes, CST you're reasoning for voting for EAP seems very weak to me, and thus suspicious so id like to see you in the runoff also. i wont be voting partners with you this round sarah, but you can keep your vote for me if you'd like.
Without the Mafia knowing who the inspector is, they usually want to try and whack the inspector ASAP. While doing this, Mafia usually want to try and set someone up as well. Now, if Surf voted for a Mafia member in Day 1, it doesn't make as much sense to whack Surf, because that would bring attention right to the Mafia's doorstep. More likely is that I think Surf voted for a Townie, and the Mafia whacked him and may try to use his whack against Scrog, or maybe Sarah questioning how many times he's played before.
I don't know, there's really not much to go on here.
i agree SFA, a 4 person run-off isn't going to do us any good. i am not even sold on george, my vote was just reciprocal, but it would be silly to change now. i am hoping that after tonight's whack we'll have more insight, since the last round was pretty atypical.
p.s. duddits, sorry to hear about your HS. as a teacher, it certainly hits a little closer to home.
Jan 16 Disclosure
Feb 7 Umphrey's McGee
Mar 15 Dropkick Murphys
May 16 Mastodon / Gojira / Kvelertak
May 31 Sharon Jones & The Dap-Kings
Jun 21 John Butler Trio
Jun 24 Lionel Richie
Jul 11 DMB
Jul 25-27 Newport Folk
Aug 19 Arcade Fire
Oct 25 Fleetwood Mac
Nov 28 Run The Jewels
Post by popsicle sarah on Feb 29, 2012 19:32:38 GMT -5
None of these three are outrageously suspicious, but I'm slightly suspicious of CST. He played the "newb" card at the beginning, but his last couple of posts sounded more enlightened, like he might be being coached.
My vote is staying where its at for now. I'm not positive on either Scrog or CST, but both have raised some suspicion. I'd def like to see some more discussion from the people in the runoff tho so I at least know we dont have 3 mafia in there!
Oh, and I will also point out that myself, Scrog, and sarah, and maybe more will be in Atlanta for Radiohead tomorrow night so I will be very MIA until Fri evening. But will check in from my phone. Maybe Scrog will get drunk and confess he's mafia so I can change my vote lol.
Post by nicthedick85 on Mar 1, 2012 6:24:13 GMT -5
Well I voted for Scrog in both rounds because he switched his vote to me because I switched votes first. I only switched my vote so there was no chance of there being an 11 way tie. So I have my suspicions he is mafia. Any more questions feel free to ask.