Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo in 2013!!
Vote Chart Quacker >> Bacon >> MC MC >> LD >> EAP >> Boneroo >> Hakuna Mike D >> Boneroo >> NBF >> Hakuna Hakuna >> SFA >> MC Bacon >> Viking >> Boneroo >> MC EAP >> MC SFA >> Hakuna Viking >> Hakunna
Left to Vote LD Boneroo NBF
Ref Notes The round will close when all votes are cast or at the end of the weekend, whichever happens first. Ideally we can start the "night" tonight so that we can get the first whack and guess in by Sunday night and move onto Day 2.
Post by NothingButFlowers on Feb 15, 2013 13:39:42 GMT -5
I'm not going to vote until tomorrow morning. I have been keeping up but I still need to think more and process, and I don't feel capable of accomplishing that today.
This is a tough vote to cast. The more I read back, the more I'm calling into question the actions of players not in this runoff. On one hand, MikeDs post on page 3 about Hakuna possibly needing another person in the runoff to save a mafia member made some sense. On the other hand, with MC, I'm still trying to justify his reasoning on forgetting who he voted for, as well ad his constant finger pointing In my direction. It's not lining up for me. This round has been a bit of a roller coaster for me, and I'm not sure if I should feel complimented by MC feeling I'm being coached by an experienced mafia player, or insulted that Quacker feels I'm a useless noob. Clearly 2 different trains of thought here. Either way, I don't take any of it to heart. All in all, I couldn't narrow down who was most likely mafia out of the two of them, so I narrowed down who is least likely to be the inspector IMO Nothing personal, and as I said, this was not an easy decision
I'm not going to vote until tomorrow morning. I have been keeping up but I still need to think more and process, and I don't feel capable of accomplishing that today.
The let's try toget this done by Sunday night. Have a good weekend folks.
This is a tough vote to cast. The more I read back, the more I'm calling into question the actions of players not in this runoff. On one hand, MikeDs post on page 3 about Hakuna possibly needing another person in the runoff to save a mafia member made some sense. On the other hand, with MC, I'm still trying to justify his reasoning on forgetting who he voted for, as well ad his constant finger pointing In my direction. It's not lining up for me. This round has been a bit of a roller coaster for me, and I'm not sure if I should feel complimented by MC feeling I'm being coached by an experienced mafia player, or insulted that Quacker feels I'm a useless noob. Clearly 2 different trains of thought here. Either way, I don't take any of it to heart. All in all, I couldn't narrow down who was most likely mafia out of the two of them, so I narrowed down who is least likely to be the inspector IMO Nothing personal, and as I said, this was not an easy decision
Boneroo>>>MikeD>>>LD>>>Bacon>>>MC
Dude there's no reasoning behind it it was a f*cking mistake. I don know how many times I can say it. I've also stopped pointing the finger at you recently. The only reason I thought you were being coached was that you played the noob card.
No one has made a big deal about this accident except for Quacker. Either the rest aren't paying attention as much, or Quacker is trying to make a bigger deal of it than it really is, and is succeeding.
Good point MC. EAP, MikeD and SFA have all been very quiet. Thoughts? I'm staying on MC for now but am not set in stone.
I read over the tread a few times but their really isn't any moves that I feel stick out more then others. In other words, every time I think something might be suspicious. I can make a case why it could also be a complete innocent move. I just don't feel comfortable leading things one way or the other because I could be dead wrong, at this point.
Last Edit: Feb 15, 2013 18:30:08 GMT -5 by superfurryanimal - Back to Top
EAP reciprocated my vote in the beginning but since we've been actually discussing she's been rather silent. What's your take on all this, EAP?
i don't really say much in the first round. neither one of you has extreme stacking one way or the other, so to be honest i feel like both of you are probably townies.
i think some of the prior vote switches are a little bit fishy, but we are going to have to see what happens after the whack.
Mar 14 Sheepdogs/Fitz & The Tantrums/City & Colour (Austin)
Mar 15 Jim James (Austin)
Apr 26 Jim James (Boston)
May 4 Clutch & The Sword (Portland ME)
Jun 8 DMB (Hartford)
Jun 21 Jim James (Northampton MA)
Jul 27-28 Newport Folk
Oct 25-27 MOEMS
Good point MC. EAP, MikeD and SFA have all been very quiet. Thoughts? I'm staying on MC for now but am not set in stone.
At least in the past few games, I don't recall EAP, SFA or Myself being all that vocal. The last game I played as mafia I mentioned how quiet I thought SFA was early on among the mafia PM's. I looked back and it wasn't that odd, it fit right in with the majority of games he had recently played. I can't speak as much for EAP, but I don't recall her being all that vocal right off the bat, could be wrong though as I haven't gone back and looked and quite frankly don't know off hand. As for me, that seems to come up just about every game I play now too, it's almost as routine for me as hearing about how Mike D is always mafia. Some other folks might differ, but I don't see anything odd with the three of us being on the quieter/lower post count side of things at this point.
This is a tough vote to cast. The more I read back, the more I'm calling into question the actions of players not in this runoff. On one hand, MikeDs post on page 3 about Hakuna possibly needing another person in the runoff to save a mafia member made some sense. On the other hand, with MC, I'm still trying to justify his reasoning on forgetting who he voted for, as well ad his constant finger pointing In my direction. It's not lining up for me. This round has been a bit of a roller coaster for me, and I'm not sure if I should feel complimented by MC feeling I'm being coached by an experienced mafia player, or insulted that Quacker feels I'm a useless noob. Clearly 2 different trains of thought here. Either way, I don't take any of it to heart. All in all, I couldn't narrow down who was most likely mafia out of the two of them, so I narrowed down who is least likely to be the inspector IMO Nothing personal, and as I said, this was not an easy decision
Boneroo>>>MikeD>>>LD>>>Bacon>>>MC
LD >>> everything before this >>> Hakuna
I got a vibe about Boneroo. So if he's Mafia, could he be protecting Hakuna?
Mar 14 Sheepdogs/Fitz & The Tantrums/City & Colour (Austin)
Mar 15 Jim James (Austin)
Apr 26 Jim James (Boston)
May 4 Clutch & The Sword (Portland ME)
Jun 8 DMB (Hartford)
Jun 21 Jim James (Northampton MA)
Jul 27-28 Newport Folk
Oct 25-27 MOEMS
This is a tough vote to cast. The more I read back, the more I'm calling into question the actions of players not in this runoff. On one hand, MikeDs post on page 3 about Hakuna possibly needing another person in the runoff to save a mafia member made some sense. On the other hand, with MC, I'm still trying to justify his reasoning on forgetting who he voted for, as well ad his constant finger pointing In my direction. It's not lining up for me. This round has been a bit of a roller coaster for me, and I'm not sure if I should feel complimented by MC feeling I'm being coached by an experienced mafia player, or insulted that Quacker feels I'm a useless noob. Clearly 2 different trains of thought here. Either way, I don't take any of it to heart. All in all, I couldn't narrow down who was most likely mafia out of the two of them, so I narrowed down who is least likely to be the inspector IMO Nothing personal, and as I said, this was not an easy decision
Boneroo>>>MikeD>>>LD>>>Bacon>>>MC
LD >>> everything before this >>> Hakuna
I got a vibe about Boneroo. So if he's Mafia, could he be protecting Hakuna?
Fair enough. Can't blame you for feelin like that with the way I started out. Just glad I'm not NBF right now.
Post by NothingButFlowers on Feb 16, 2013 10:34:31 GMT -5
I think it's unlikely that either of these two are mafia, but I'm going with hakuna because it was 3-3-3-2, with mc having the 2, and then it got turned around to him being in the two-person runoff, which makes me think it is a little more unlikely that he is mafia.
Vote Chart NBF >> Hakuna LD >> Hakuna Boneroo >> mC Quacker >> Bacon >> MC MC >> LD >> EAP >> Boneroo >> Hakuna Mike D >> Boneroo >> NBF >> Hakuna Hakuna >> SFA >> MC Bacon >> Viking >> Boneroo >> MC EAP >> MC SFA >> Hakuna Viking >> Hakunna
Left to Vote
Ref Notes I should end the round right now since everyone has voted. But to not offend anyone, I will close it tomorrow during the day to leave enough time to start Day 2 Sunday night.
Mar 14 Sheepdogs/Fitz & The Tantrums/City & Colour (Austin)
Mar 15 Jim James (Austin)
Apr 26 Jim James (Boston)
May 4 Clutch & The Sword (Portland ME)
Jun 8 DMB (Hartford)
Jun 21 Jim James (Northampton MA)
Jul 27-28 Newport Folk
Oct 25-27 MOEMS
This has mafia all over it. Acting like inspector and putting the ultra-vulnerable LD in the run-off.
If LD ends up in the run-off Boneroo absolutely must too.
Baconus66>>Boneroo
It could be that mafia took some of his wording as inspector hints. But this is fare from solid evidence, as Bacon tends to talk this strait forward and switch votes when he feels he should.
In class can't explain but bone isn't the place to be me thinks
Bacon. ***) mc. ( that's a vote)
This is after the runoff started. He suggests moving the votes away from Bonnaroo and then votes MC. What strikes me as strange is this a pretty big turn about in his thinking. Did the mafia take note of this or did he just have a change of heart on Boneroo? Either way, he post later in the day suggesting a second runoff with Hakuna and MC.
These are really the only people he brought up, which means the mafia through he was hinting at one of these names or they saw him as trying to influence the runoff away from the way his possible given name was voting. Meaning his protective stance for LD and , later on, Boneroo might have been a red flag.
Bacon voting for Viking off the bat. He moved off of him quickly and did say it was because he finds him annoying but it could be something. Bacon jumping on MC but he doesn't really clarify why. He takes Boneroo out of the runoff but doesn't really do much to help his own position in it. The runoff expanding to just about everybody playing.
Well, I originally voted Hakuna because it looked like he was expanding a runoff which had Quacker, Bacon, and Boneroo in it. At the time, I thought the 2 mafia members were Bacon and Quacker, but after Bacon got whacked, it looks like I was wrong about Bacon. I am willing to give him the benefit of the doubt, but I still think we should grill Quacker a bit. In addition to the day 1 reasoning, Quacker was the other vote on LD (in addition to Boneroo). Even though it was his VP, it is worth taking a look at.
