Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Post by RadioSpirit on Jan 9, 2011 11:21:46 GMT -5
The fact is, for a big classic headliner, there is nobody realistic that would be as awesome as Paul. I don't see Neil as the traditional big Saturday act, and Bowie/Waters/etc all seem unlikely.
You could certainly make an argument that a newer band like Radiohead would be better, but as far as old legends go....c'mon, it's Paul McCartney.
everything i have heard about the new lineup for the pumpkins is that they are terrible live.
everything i have heard about Macca live is that he is still amazing.
so lets just say i will have to disagree with you on this one. outside of Prince, Macca is prob the biggest name that can be had IMO.
^this. I saw SP at forecastle and they were awful.
The only reason I ever considered going to see Smashing Pumpkins was because Explosions In The Sky was opening for them a few years ago.
But, yeah, aside from some of Siamese Dream, I really think Pumpkins has been one of the most hideously overrated bands of the last few decades. Plus, their live show supposedly blows.
The fact is, for a big classic headliner, there is nobody realistic that would be as awesome as Paul. I don't see Neil as the traditional big Saturday act, and Bowie/Waters/etc all seem unlikely.
Rolling Stones? I would actually prefer them, but that's also because I've seen McCartney recently and have never seen The Stones. Are they still considered a possibility?
Too much maybe but hey, it's an anniversary.
FRI: The Black Keys > Paul McCartney > My Morning Jacket (LN) SAT: Arcade Fire > Rolling Stones > Daft Punk (LN) SUN: Neil Young > Phish
^this. I saw SP at forecastle and they were awful.
The only reason I ever considered going to see Smashing Pumpkins was because Explosions In The Sky was opening for them a few years ago.
But, yeah, aside from some of Siamese Dream, I really think Pumpkins has been one of the most hideously overrated bands of the last few decades. Plus, their live show supposedly blows.
Gish was actually pretty good as well, and yes there live show is terrible.
Rolling Stones? I would actually prefer them, but that's also because I've seen McCartney recently and have never seen The Stones. Are they still considered a possibility?
Honestly, I would love to see The Rolling Stones once before they're gone for good. But I was just saying Paul is more known for still being in top state than The Stones are, with a lot of people saying they're just a shadow of their former selves. I'd take them, but a lot of other people might be turned off.
I'm sorry guys, but I can't be the only person who feels this way.
Everyone in here can name 8 to 10 live acts that would be a better show. He is just past his prime, even though though its sad to say it. Were talking about LIVE music. Coldplay...Daft Punk...Clapton...Muse....Foo Fighters....Rage Against The Machine...R.E.M....Smashing Pumpkins (anyone who has seen the new lineup can attest to this)...U2....Stone Temple Pilots (most nights)...even the Rolling Stones would be better than Paul and we know theyve been on a slide. Are any bands as influential as Paul.... No way. But they all put on a better show right now. Does anyone else want bands in thier prime for headliners instead of shooting a huge wad on Paul?
If were going with a "classic" artist how about Peter Gabriel.....Depeche Mode..George Clinton and P-Funk?
Having seen Paul McCartney in Atlanta summer 09, I can tell you he is way better than any other band you named live. The only close comparison that I've seen was Daft Punk when I saw them at Vegoose, and I'm sure the Stones are good live, but they're known for being a parody of their former selves. Paul puts on an utterly amazing show still.
Rolling Stones? I would actually prefer them, but that's also because I've seen McCartney recently and have never seen The Stones. Are they still considered a possibility?
Too much maybe but hey, it's an anniversary.
FRI: The Black Keys > Paul McCartney > My Morning Jacket (LN) SAT: Arcade Fire > Rolling Stones > Daft Punk (LN)