Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Do you have any qualms about this? Like why was Dan the whack? It confirms he's town and he was already believed to be town...and with 3 votes immediately going on Carini I just get suspicious.
Kdogg aint dumb. He's been around this block many a time. The degree to which Zig aggressively feuded with him...then he was whacked... I don't know. I really still do have a funny feeling about Zig.
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Bringing this to the forefront for town to look at. Voting carini out tonight instead of Zig is an extremely risky move. If zig is inspector but we kill him tonight, that still gives us another day. Only carini would remain, in this scenario.
However, if Viking was our real inspector after all, and we keep Zig alive today, two Mafia remain (zig & Mike D). Mafia would win. This is also applies to the third (and least likely) theory, in which it was a double fake. Still, gotta kill Zig to see another day.
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Town, I understand why you would want to kill my today, however, I have all 3 Mafia, and I promise we would win on Day 4. If you don't follow my advice, you are looking at a Day 5 with probably Danbob as the swing vote.
These were some of my comments from Day 3. Mafia's only play is for a Day 5. At this point, if you kill me, either Potent or Rummy will be the deciding vote on Day 5 (with Mike D and Carini also in Day 5.
IMO, killing me off at this point in the game is pointless. If you believe me, Carini should be the vote. Voting me off now on Day 4 only delays the same decision that will need to be made on Day 5: Carini or someone else.
Potent / Rummy - the two of you are the swing votes. If you vote me off, one of you will have to make the same decision on Day 5 that could be made on Day 4.
Potent / Rummy - the two of you are the swing votes. If you vote me off, one of you will have to make the same decision on Day 5 that could be made on Day 4.
So we would win in that case. That sounds good to me, where is the downside?
^^What new information would you gain by delaying to Day 5? If you kill Carini Day 4, game overr, town wins. If you kill me, either you or Rummy get whacked, and then the non-whacked player chooses between Mike D and Carini.
If you were going to be able to obtain new information that could help you make a decision, I would say delay until Day 5, but in this situation, you don't gain anything.
I'm changing my vote out of concern for the quick stacking.
Potent > Carini > ZIG
This is quite curious for a couple reasons. Did you expect Zig or I to vote differently? Both you and Rummy decided against going for the safe play of voting out Zig last round, instead voting SFA.
Potent & Rummy - how did the Danbob whack change your mind about this? Not trying to put words in your mouth or reason for you, but that is the only new information we have since then.
I'm changing my vote out of concern for the quick stacking.
Potent > Carini > ZIG
This is quite curious for a couple reasons. Did you expect Zig or I to vote differently? Both you and Rummy decided against going for the safe play of voting out Zig last round, instead voting SFA.
Potent & Rummy - how did the Danbob whack change your mind about this? Not trying to put words in your mouth or reason for you, but that is the only new information we have since then.
Frankly it's making me take a second look at Rummy. We all knew Dan was town, he's a new guy, so the whack was clearly meant to throw off somewhere.
Knowing that Carini would vote ZIG, I wanted to see where Rummy put her vote.
Playing out this string, if there are 2 mafia left I feel like ZIG has to be one of them. If there's one left, voting ZIG off doesn't harm the town. If the final 3 are me, Mike, and Carini, I will be voting Carini with you. If you substitute Rummy in for me, I hope the two of you figure it out. If it's me Rummy and Carini I will have to think long and hard.
I think voting out ZIG is the safest for the town here. It's not that I don't believe him, I think I do. But I like to make sure.
This is quite curious for a couple reasons. Did you expect Zig or I to vote differently? Both you and Rummy decided against going for the safe play of voting out Zig last round, instead voting SFA.
Potent & Rummy - how did the Danbob whack change your mind about this? Not trying to put words in your mouth or reason for you, but that is the only new information we have since then.
Frankly it's making me take a second look at Rummy. We all knew Dan was town, he's a new guy, so the whack was clearly meant to throw off somewhere.
Knowing that Carini would vote ZIG, I wanted to see where Rummy put her vote.
Playing out this string, if there are 2 mafia left I feel like ZIG has to be one of them. If there's one left, voting ZIG off doesn't harm the town. If the final 3 are me, Mike, and Carini, I will be voting Carini with you. If you substitute Rummy in for me, I hope the two of you figure it out. If it's me Rummy and Carini I will have to think long and hard.
I think voting out ZIG is the safest for the town here. It's not that I don't believe him, I think I do. But I like to make sure.
How about the whack was because Dan was a likely Zig voter?
Also, If you believe Zig and will automatically vote me over Mike D in a hypothetical final 3, how can you have any suspicion of Rummy at all? They only possible way she could be mafia is the double fake
This is quite curious for a couple reasons. Did you expect Zig or I to vote differently? Both you and Rummy decided against going for the safe play of voting out Zig last round, instead voting SFA.
Potent & Rummy - how did the Danbob whack change your mind about this? Not trying to put words in your mouth or reason for you, but that is the only new information we have since then.
Frankly it's making me take a second look at Rummy. We all knew Dan was town, he's a new guy, so the whack was clearly meant to throw off somewhere.
Knowing that Carini would vote ZIG, I wanted to see where Rummy put her vote.
Playing out this string, if there are 2 mafia left I feel like ZIG has to be one of them. If there's one left, voting ZIG off doesn't harm the town. If the final 3 are me, Mike, and Carini, I will be voting Carini with you. If you substitute Rummy in for me, I hope the two of you figure it out. If it's me Rummy and Carini I will have to think long and hard.
I think voting out ZIG is the safest for the town here. It's not that I don't believe him, I think I do. But I like to make sure.
I think this is exactly why you should be voting Carini on Day 4. I feel comfortable that you would vote off Carini on Day 5, but if you are unsure about Rummy, by delaying until Day 5, you open up the possibility of getting whacked and then Rummy would be the deciding vote.
JR usually sleeps on planes so he expected to be up at a normal time, but there was a 2 year screaming behind him the whole flight home last night. He's in bed catching up on sleep.
JR usually sleeps on planes so he expected to be up at a normal time, but there was a 2 year screaming behind him the whole flight home last night. He's in bed catching up on sleep.
Sorry for the late closing. I wish I was drunk on the plane, maybe I would have slept through the screeching toddler one seat behind me. If I would have thought ahead to the fact that I'd be out of town for a week I probably wouldn't have volunteered to ref.
Day 4 is over. ZIG is dead. Mafia send me your whack, Inspector send me your guess.
Last Edit: Jul 15, 2016 13:50:07 GMT -5 by JR - Back to Top
I'm surprised I wasn't the whack in the previous Night, but it has gotta be me tonight. If it isn't.......well, I will bite my tongue on saying too too much here.
But I am going to appeal to Potent for a moment, since he is obviously gonna be the swing vote. Carini will vote Mike D, Mike D will vote Carini, and then Potent will decide between the two. I get that Carini isn't the most responsive or helpful townie (sry, Carini). His response after zig's accusation wasn't the most trust-inspiring thing, either. I won't argue that. But before you place your vote on Carini, just think long and hard about whether you really believe all of what Zig has said this game. His claims, as well as his disposition. I can't tell you what to do, but simply encourage you to not be rash in the decision.
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
