Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
With Jason Roeder being in Neurosis.. I choose Sleep as an UFDA as well!
Is this okay since it's decently likely someone may pick High On Fire during the draft taking the rights to Matt Pike in the process?
Totally looked over that tbh. Because I looked it up and wanted to make made sure no one else played in another band, even messaged cdevaney to be sure.. Guess I missed High On Fire.
Is this okay since it's decently likely someone may pick High On Fire during the draft taking the rights to Matt Pike in the process?
Totally looked over that tbh. Because I looked it up and wanted to make made sure no one else played in another band, even messaged cdevaney to be sure.. Guess I missed High On Fire.
Is this okay since it's decently likely someone may pick High On Fire during the draft taking the rights to Matt Pike in the process?
Bing is the only one with rights to Sleep but if another member of Sleep is drafted by someone else then Sleep would be blocked from everybody's lineup.
The only way to claim a UDFA is if you have the rights to a member and none of the other members of that UDFA play in other acts that can be drafted. The previous example that was used is Blur. Damon Albarn was drafted with Gorillaz and none of the other members of Blur are active in any other acts, basically making Blur an exclusive-rights free agent to the person who drafted Gorillaz.
Is this okay since it's decently likely someone may pick High On Fire during the draft taking the rights to Matt Pike in the process?
Bing is the only one with rights to Sleep but if another member of Sleep is drafted by someone else then Sleep would be blocked from everybody's lineup.
The only way to claim a UDFA is if you have the rights to a member and none of the other members of that UDFA play in other acts that can be drafted. The previous example that was used is Blur. Damon Albarn was drafted with Gorillaz and none of the other members of Blur are active in any other acts, basically making Blur an exclusive-rights free agent to the person who drafted Gorillaz.
These rules make no sense. I'm sorry I agreed to help Vieux .
i feel like this ones been beaten to death tho...
Strokes nets Hammond, Voidz; Voidz or Hammond nets just Strokes, not all three.
Planetarium nets National, but not El Vey.
Drafting Sleep would have given Om, Neurosis, High On Fire.
If someone drafts Om or High On Fire, no one gets Sleep.
Vieux has been told she can't have APC. After being told no one else could have them. She assumed that meant she could and was planning all along to pick them as a free agent and not only that, they were going to be a headliner. So now she's screwed. All because James Iha is with Smashing Pumpkins and soneone drafted them. So now I'm in charge of her draft while she's gone and I'm confused and mad and kinda don't even want to do it anymore.
Strokes nets Hammond, Voidz; Voidz or Hammond nets just Strokes, not all three.
Planetarium nets National, but not El Vey.
Drafting Sleep would have given Om, Neurosis, High On Fire.
If someone drafts Om or High On Fire, no one gets Sleep.
Vieux has been told she can't have APC. After being told no one else could have them. She assumed that meant she could and was planning all along to pick them as a free agent and not only that, they were going to be a headliner. So now she's screwed. All because James Iha is with Smashing Pumpkins and soneone drafted them. So now I'm in charge of her draft while she's gone and I'm confused and mad and kinda don't even want to do it anymore.
patience. I'm in talks with other people trying to see what we can do to loosen up the Pumpkins for her. Don't be angry yet.
so if someone drafted el vey and then the national before hambone, he would lose the national?
No. If someone drafted El Vey before tЯist♡n drafted The National then nobody could get get The National.
sang_xcx , yeah i think it's dumb, I've made that statement a few times. But we nailed down that a band like APC with shared members needed to be drafted a minute ago. I will say it wasn't super clear before she drafted Tool, but as I said to arcuse, whatever Tool is fucking sick.
*the Strokes/Voidz/Hammond example was a week before that one. She liked both of them so idk.
I think a better argument would be that there was no Billy + Iha at the time of this draft, just some strong (which turned out to be true) rumors.
Strokes nets Hammond, Voidz; Voidz or Hammond nets just Strokes, not all three.
Planetarium nets National, but not El Vey.
Drafting Sleep would have given Om, Neurosis, High On Fire.
If someone drafts Om or High On Fire, no one gets Sleep.
Vieux has been told she can't have APC. After being told no one else could have them. She assumed that meant she could and was planning all along to pick them as a free agent and not only that, they were going to be a headliner. So now she's screwed. All because James Iha is with Smashing Pumpkins and soneone drafted them. So now I'm in charge of her draft while she's gone and I'm confused and mad and kinda don't even want to do it anymore.
plenty of headliners left she can get. 21 pilots, j cole, drake. it could be STACKED!
now who got spoon again? reminder:
Kendrick Lamar / Muse / LCD Soundsystem
My Morning Jacket (2 Sets) / The XX / Weezer / Ice Cube
Tenacious D / Ween / Portugal. The Man / TV on the Radio
Jamie xx / Cage the Elephant / Ratatat (late nite) / Mac Demarco
Vieux has been told she can't have APC. After being told no one else could have them. She assumed that meant she could and was planning all along to pick them as a free agent and not only that, they were going to be a headliner. So now she's screwed. All because James Iha is with Smashing Pumpkins and soneone drafted them. So now I'm in charge of her draft while she's gone and I'm confused and mad and kinda don't even want to do it anymore.
plenty of headliners left she can get. 21 pilots, j cole, drake. it could be STACKED!
now who got spoon again? reminder:
Kendrick Lamar / Muse / LCD Soundsystem
My Morning Jacket (2 Sets) / The XX / Weezer / Ice Cube
Tenacious D / Ween / Portugal. The Man / TV on the Radio
Jamie xx / Cage the Elephant / Ratatat (late nite) / Mac Demarco
No. If someone drafted El Vey before tЯist♡n drafted The National then nobody could get get The National.
sang_xcx , yeah i think it's dumb, I've made that statement a few times. But we nailed down that a band like APC with shared members needed to be drafted a minute ago. I will say it wasn't super clear before she drafted Tool, but as I said to arcuse, whatever Tool is fucking sick.
*the Strokes/Voidz/Hammond example was a week before that one. She liked both of them so idk.
I think a better argument would be that there was no Billy + Iha at the time of this draft, just some strong (which turned out to be true) rumors.
She was confused by all of the rules. That's part of the reason she asked me to help. She was working under the assumption the entire time that APC was going to be hers. I was too, but I was about to post something about it and something said run it by someone first and then it came out that she can't have APC because of Iha. It's a nonsense rule. APC is Maynard and Billy, if you're going to have a rule like that, at least make it about members that are vital to the band. James playing with his original band shouldn't prevent her from having Maynard's band. These rules are the reason I didn't play, but I decided to get involved again for reason. Love the game, hate the rules.
sang_xcx , yeah i think it's dumb, I've made that statement a few times. But we nailed down that a band like APC with shared members needed to be drafted a minute ago. I will say it wasn't super clear before she drafted Tool, but as I said to arcuse, whatever Tool is fucking sick.
*the Strokes/Voidz/Hammond example was a week before that one. She liked both of them so idk.
I think a better argument would be that there was no Billy + Iha at the time of this draft, just some strong (which turned out to be true) rumors.
She was confused by all of the rules. That's part of the reason she asked me to help. She was working under the assumption the entire time that APC was going to be hers. I was too, but I was about to post something about it and something said run it by someone first and then it came out that she can't have APC because of Iha. It's a nonsense rule. APC is Maynard and Billy, if you're going to have a rule like that, at least make it about members that are vital to the band. James playing with his original band shouldn't prevent her from having Maynard's band. These rules are the reason I didn't play, but I decided to get involved again for reason. Love the game, hate the rules.
I mean, this is not a hard and fast rule. Krisp let Mardude have JRAD even though this rule would seemingly mean he shouldn't be able to have them (unless they subbed the bassist). Can't whomever has the Pumpkins just say, hey, it's cool if she takes APC?
She was confused by all of the rules. That's part of the reason she asked me to help. She was working under the assumption the entire time that APC was going to be hers. I was too, but I was about to post something about it and something said run it by someone first and then it came out that she can't have APC because of Iha. It's a nonsense rule. APC is Maynard and Billy, if you're going to have a rule like that, at least make it about members that are vital to the band. James playing with his original band shouldn't prevent her from having Maynard's band. These rules are the reason I didn't play, but I decided to get involved again for reason. Love the game, hate the rules.
I mean, this is not a hard and fast rule. Krisp let Mardude have JRAD even though this rule would seemingly mean he shouldn't be able to have them (unless they subbed the bassist). Can't whomever has the Pumpkins just say, hey, it's cool if she takes APC?
cdevaney said no that (which next game, he shouldn't be playing and making rules) walaka was fine with her having APC and is even been talking to me about trading them to her. It's just frustrating that all of the rules are getting in the way of the fun of the game.
I mean, this is not a hard and fast rule. Krisp let Mardude have JRAD even though this rule would seemingly mean he shouldn't be able to have them (unless they subbed the bassist). Can't whomever has the Pumpkins just say, hey, it's cool if she takes APC?
cdevaney said no that (which next game, he shouldn't be playing and making rules) walaka was fine with her having APC and is even been talking to me about trading them to her. It's just frustrating that all of the rules are getting in the way of the fun of the game.
cdevaney said no that (which next game, he shouldn't be playing and making rules) walaka was fine with her having APC and is even been talking to me about trading them to her. It's just frustrating that all of the rules are getting in the way of the fun of the game.
oh, well that's odd
I just finalized something for you to work on a game. I feel cdevaney is doing a great job and I couldn't imagine running the game without having a stake in it. It seems like lots of work.
I just finalized something for you to work on a game. I feel cdevaney is doing a great job and I couldn't imagine running the game without having a stake in it. It seems like lots of work.
He's doing a great job of keeping track of everything. But all of the rules are overcomplicating it and making it less fun (I had 2 people pm me saying this after my post).
Krisp let Mardude have JRAD even though this rule would seemingly mean he shouldn't be able to have them
I must have missed this; it shouldn't be allowed. We voted that we can't trade rights. If we can't trade rights, we shouldn't be able to give them away either.