Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Krisp let Mardude have JRAD even though this rule would seemingly mean he shouldn't be able to have them
I must have missed this; it shouldn't be allowed. We voted that we can't trade rights. If we can't trade rights, we shouldn't be able to give them away either.
To be fair, I guess JRAD has played a few shows without Dave when Ween is on tour. It's not an exact comparison (my bad).
Jaz: gives Missy Elliott, gets Fatboy Slim and Modeselektor walaka: Gives Modeselektor, Dixie Chicks and A$AP Mob, gets Travis Scott and the Red Hot Chili Peppers cdevaney: Gives Travis Scott, Fatboy Slim and the Red Hot Chili Peppers, gets Missy Elliott, the Dixie Chicks and A$AP Mob
I just finalized something for you to work on a game. I feel cdevaney is doing a great job and I couldn't imagine running the game without having a stake in it. It seems like lots of work.
He's doing a great job of keeping track of everything. But all of the rules are overcomplicating it and making it less fun (I had 2 people pm me saying this after my post).
but the rules are being voted on by the people. Not just being implemented
I mean, this is not a hard and fast rule. Krisp let Mardude have JRAD even though this rule would seemingly mean he shouldn't be able to have them (unless they subbed the bassist). Can't whomever has the Pumpkins just say, hey, it's cool if she takes APC?
cdevaney said no that (which next game, he shouldn't be playing and making rules) walaka was fine with her having APC and is even been talking to me about trading them to her. It's just frustrating that all of the rules are getting in the way of the fun of the game.
there should be a point system applied to each act that each fantasy drafter is allowed a max points spent. Then you dont have all these people with 10 headliner acts and if you did book like that you'd gut your undercard.
He's doing a great job of keeping track of everything. But all of the rules are overcomplicating it and making it less fun (I had 2 people pm me saying this after my post).
but the rules are being voted on by the people. Not just being implemented
Yea, but obviously some people are either confused by some of the rules and obviously some people disagree with them.
cdevaney said no that (which next game, he shouldn't be playing and making rules) walaka was fine with her having APC and is even been talking to me about trading them to her. It's just frustrating that all of the rules are getting in the way of the fun of the game.
there should be a point system applied to each act that each fantasy drafter is allowed a max points spent. Then you dont have all these people with 10 headliner acts and if you did book like that you'd gut your undercard.
I mean, this is not a hard and fast rule. Krisp let Mardude have JRAD even though this rule would seemingly mean he shouldn't be able to have them (unless they subbed the bassist). Can't whomever has the Pumpkins just say, hey, it's cool if she takes APC?
cdevaney said no that (which next game, he shouldn't be playing and making rules) walaka was fine with her having APC and is even been talking to me about trading them to her. It's just frustrating that all of the rules are getting in the way of the fun of the game.
I said no because we voted (Vieux included) not to allow individual members' rights to be traded to allow for crossovers like this.
FTR, the reason that the Ween/JRAD is different is because it was established that they JRAD plays shows without the guy from Ween. In fact, they are both playing separate shows on the same night at some point in the future. Whoever drafted Ween was satisfied that the JRAD pick did not infringe on his rights.
cdevaney said no that (which next game, he shouldn't be playing and making rules) walaka was fine with her having APC and is even been talking to me about trading them to her. It's just frustrating that all of the rules are getting in the way of the fun of the game.
I said no because we voted (Vieux included) not to allow individual members' rights to be traded to allow for crossovers like this.
FTR, the reason that the Ween/JRAD is different is because it was established that they JRAD plays shows without the guy from Ween. In fact, they are both playing separate shows on the same night at some point in the future. Whoever drafted Ween was satisfied that the JRAD pick did not infringe on his rights.
cdevaney said no that (which next game, he shouldn't be playing and making rules) walaka was fine with her having APC and is even been talking to me about trading them to her. It's just frustrating that all of the rules are getting in the way of the fun of the game.
I said no because we voted (Vieux included) not to allow individual members' rights to be traded to allow for crossovers like this.
FTR, the reason that the Ween/JRAD is different is because it was established that they JRAD plays shows without the guy from Ween. In fact, they are both playing separate shows on the same night at some point in the future. Whoever drafted Ween was satisfied that the JRAD pick did not infringe on his rights.
Jaz: gives Missy Elliott, gets Fatboy Slim and Modeselektor walaka: Gives Modeselektor, Dixie Chicks and A$AP Mob, gets Travis Scott and the Red Hot Chili Peppers cdevaney: Gives Travis Scott, Fatboy Slim and the Red Hot Chili Peppers, gets Missy Elliott, the Dixie Chicks and A$AP Mob
We're all aware this is a pretend draft with pretend bands and no real prize, right? Jeebus.
Right, so shouldn't the rules be more relaxed? Why so many damn rules? Instead of saying this guy in in 2 bands (who are both actively touring) and can't play at 2 different festivals. I think he just moved up off of this is Bonnaroo, 20 Bonnaroos, all taking place on one weekend, it would work a lot better.
We're all aware this is a pretend draft with pretend bands and no real prize, right? Jeebus.
Right, so shouldn't the rules be more relaxed? Why so many damn rules? Instead of saying this guy in in 2 bands (who are both actively touring) and can't play at 2 different festivals. I think he just moved up off of this is Bonnaroo, 20 Bonnaroos, all taking place on one weekend, it would work a lot better.
honestly this rule is a good thing especially after last seasons mess.
We're all aware this is a pretend draft with pretend bands and no real prize, right? Jeebus.
Right, so shouldn't the rules be more relaxed? Why so many damn rules? Instead of saying this guy in in 2 bands (who are both actively touring) and can't play at 2 different festivals. I think he just moved up off of this is Bonnaroo, 20 Bonnaroos, all taking place on one weekend, it would work a lot better.
In a perfect world, yes, but certain people here will just abuse the rules because they want to win a meaningless prize.
Holy shit is Sang rage quitting a draft he's not even participating in? Lmfao
Basically. But if I wasn't helping Vieux this wouldn't have come out until free agents when she puts APC on her lineup as a headliner and then she gets pissed off when she's told she can't have them. I mean, she just misunderstood the rule and it caused her to miss out on a bigger headliner. I'm just fighting for her so she's not completely screwed.
We're all aware this is a pretend draft with pretend bands and no real prize, right? Jeebus.
Right, so shouldn't the rules be more relaxed? Why so many damn rules? Instead of saying this guy in in 2 bands (who are both actively touring) and can't play at 2 different festivals. I think he just moved up off of this is Bonnaroo, 20 Bonnaroos, all taking place on one weekend, it would work a lot better.
Right, so shouldn't the rules be more relaxed? Why so many damn rules? Instead of saying this guy in in 2 bands (who are both actively touring) and can't play at 2 different festivals. I think he just moved up off of this is Bonnaroo, 20 Bonnaroos, all taking place on one weekend, it would work a lot better.
In a perfect world, yes, but certain people here will just abuse the rules because they want to win a meaningless prize.
Wait, I thought the winner could go to Hangout with the prize money?
We're all aware this is a pretend draft with pretend bands and no real prize, right? Jeebus.
Right, so shouldn't the rules be more relaxed? Why so many damn rules? Instead of saying this guy in in 2 bands (who are both actively touring) and can't play at 2 different festivals. I think he just moved up off of this is Bonnaroo, 20 Bonnaroos, all taking place on one weekend, it would work a lot better.
It's a learning process - some things we have to figure out as we go along. Last year we allowed members of a drafted band play other festivals, but we had to prove that they sometimes played without their respective band while their band was on tour. It was a clusterfuck, and one that wasn't anticipated. So this year to simplify things, we made the individual members exclusive to their fest - and it's gotten a little clusterfucky with regard to trade rights and the kind of stuff that we're discussing now. I think as a group we're doing just fine figuring things out for ourselves, and making changes as issues arise if necessary.