Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
At this point, I assume thor was inspector. Its baseless beyond that Kanye potentially had an opportunity to feel pressure applied from the runoff and reveal and didnt or chose not to.
All this bitching about me and that’s all you have to say? Jeez..
Ohh I'm sorry sweetheart, did I not pay enough attention to you? Color me scorned.
All this bitching about me and that’s all you have to say? Jeez..
Ohh I'm sorry sweetheart, did I not pay enough attention to you? Color me scorned.
You are a dingus. You bitch and moan that I’m not in here up to your satisfaction and then the moment I provide a good amount of information and questions, you basically ignore it. For someone that was directly called out in an inspector reveal, that’s not exactly the way to try to prove your point and sway people to your side of the argument. But what do I know, I’m just shit bird anyway.
Ohh I'm sorry sweetheart, did I not pay enough attention to you? Color me scorned.
You are a dingus. You bitch and moan that I’m not in here up to your satisfaction and then the moment I provide a good amount of information and questions, you basically ignore it. For someone that was directly called out in an inspector reveal, that’s not exactly the way to try to prove your point and sway people to your side of the argument. But what do I know, I’m just shit bird anyway.
Buddy I've been talking nonstop and have answered your questions to what should be your satisfaction in one post or another.
You are a dingus. You bitch and moan that I’m not in here up to your satisfaction and then the moment I provide a good amount of information and questions, you basically ignore it. For someone that was directly called out in an inspector reveal, that’s not exactly the way to try to prove your point and sway people to your side of the argument. But what do I know, I’m just shit bird anyway.
Buddy I've been talking nonstop and have answered your questions to what should be your satisfaction in one post or another.
You have 2 more posts than me buddy, you’ve hardly been talking “non-stop”. And no you literally answered the first question I posed in my long post from early this morning. There were plenty of other questions that were included in that post and you disregarded all of them. If you were actually wanting to have dialogue with me and get me to change my vote, Wouldn’t you want to work with people to try to get them to agree to you position? Because what you are asking is for the players to essentially disregard standard practice of keeping a supposed inspector alive and vote him out. I think most people would agree that to do that, we would probably need some convincing evidence. Other than, I know I’m town and LD’s lying, lay out your case, I will listen.
Shoulda waited for the correct tally because now I'm not sure where the votes are. Will wait for potent to do good thing and then will move to tie it up if I have the option of doing so.
Finished a reread. Taint, if LD is faking, who was the inspector, Thor or Kanye? And who was the given name? You’ve stated more than once you think I could be Mafia with LD. I don’t see how I fit into the possible scenarios based on who our inspector could be and that LD would be Mafia. You all know I wouldn’t agree to a LD fake reveal if I were Mafia with him. And if he defied me on that, I’d be the first to throw him under the bus. I still don't really know where I stand with respect to inspector. I assume Thor based on how the game transpired, as I don't feel Kanye would have waited to reveal given his Day 2 situation. I think LD’s reveal is super sketch. It reeks of desperation or straight sloppiness. He could be the inspector and just being typical LD and fucking it all up as usual. I tried to lay things out as best as I could. For Scenario 2, Carini could also fall under Mafia if you believe LD’s fake reveal is also an attempt to give fellow mafia Carini cover. His reveal is super sketch. It loses ground the more time you take to explore his voting methodology, his approach to questioning, and ultimately his reveal. I can appreciate that someone is bad at being inspector, but keep in mind that even you and I have learned to adjust our play style to accommodate a mutual opportunity to fact find and earn a W for town. If you and I can figure that out, do you find it more plausible that this game is proof of the culmination of a variety of failed and victorious attempts at Inspector (which show hes learned pretty much nothing) or that this is the culmination of several minds deciding this is the best approach to salvaging what could be an otherwise lost game?
Scenario 1 LD is Inspector
Mafia: Pablo, Taint, ? - I am curious about who would be the 3rd in this scenario, does anyone have any input there? Town: Thor, Kanye, Carini Unknown Dead: Danbob, JTR Unknown Alive: ZIG, Jaz, Maddog
For Scenario 1, the options for the third mafia are the two unknown deads (Danbob / JTR), and Jaz, and Maddog. Maddog has felt more town to me so over Jaz. In this scenario, we would need to take out Pablo, because If neither Danbob nor JTR are mafia, we lose if we leave Pablo alive. But if we keep Pablo alive and we get to Day 4, we confirm that one of Danbob / JTR was Mafia and we would have the two remaining mafia known and alive and ready be whacked on Day 4 and Day 5. So basically a chance to lose immediately, but also a confirmed townie win. - This makes scenario one do or die. You realize it didn't become do or die until I voted for LD. His timing for reveal makes no sense. It absolutely stinks of desperation. For Scenario 2, we seem a bit more screwed. If we kill LD now, we guarantee ourselves a Day 4. If we don’t, we could lose outright if all 3 mafia are alive. If we leave LD alive, and make it to a Day 4, then we confirm one of Danbob / JTR as Mafia. The question in this scenario is how to categorize a Carini. Was LD’s motivation to just sway a townie to his side by “confirming” his role, or was he actively trying to “clear” one of his mafia mates. I could see that argument going either way. I’m also curious to a mafia LD in this situation. Because even if he survives Day 3, being a fake reveal means he’d be alive on Day 4, so gig would be up at that point and he would die. So is he just delaying the inevitable, because that would assume we are close to getting all the Mafia, or is he just being a crazy Mafia, ala Dexter JR.?
I’m going to sleep and think since we have until Monday to think this out.
I feel I've covered scenario 2 pretty well in the posts that followed this morning. I apologize for making it seem as though I'm not willing to engage you shit bird, you're absolutely right. It is imperative for me to help town see what I see, as we see plainly the cost summarized in your post here. There is no value in keeping LD alive. Regardless of if you are unsure he is inspector or not, if he is he has plainly served his purpose (poorly, ineffectively, embarrassingly) and at this point any logical mafia is going to kill him off to prevent the telling of the 3rd name anyways. It will either cost you one townie or not cost you one townie to accomplish this, as no one has yet to stand up and proudly defend his actions as.. defensible.
It only looks bad if the runoff was down to you and Danbob, which the options are to vote for yourselves
I’m curious why you’re answering on behalf of JimboMattis
Tainted Opossum, this sticks out from Thor upon a reread. Thor really said a lot of nothing on D1 but this seems more interesting now. Could be nothing or something.
I've only seen him do this thing 1 time before. We will see if I'm right or not soon enough.
interesting...on page 8...LD, why did you vote carini if he was your first guess? you could have put anyone else in, you could have overstacked someone to get movement, instead you pushed carini forward. you kept bringing up that other players didn't have votes at all, and then instead of voting for say Jaz, you threw a known town into a runoff?
Option 1: If LD is inspector, he pushed a known town into the D2 runoff as the last vote in the round. That would be a terrible move. Option 2: LD is faking and he pushed his mafiamate Carini into the D2 runoff when he (LD)was already in the runoff. This seems extremely reckless. Option 3: LD is faking and he pushed townie Carini into the D2 runoff to increase the number of townies he (LD) wouldnget to face. I think it’s clear which option makes the most sense but the problem we are dealing with is that LD is not a normal person.
Post by piggy pablo on Jan 5, 2019 14:45:37 GMT -5
I flew into Atlanta today on no sleep and I'm gonna be pretty busy with family stuff, but suffice to say LD is Mafia, he's faking, and my vote on him is locked.
Dexter Jr is basically LD’s alter ego. Once in a while he starts claiming to be Dexter Jr in games and I think every time he has done that when I’ve been playing, he has been mafia.
