Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Perhaps, but JR later said directly to Tainted that he didn't feel strongly about him one way or the other. I don't think he would invalidate his own breadcrumbs.
Could be an attempt to stay alive, or you could be right.
I am keeping my vote here for now for the additional reason that It also could be they voted for each other as mafia partners and never got a chance to change and we ended up getting lucky with a 2 mafia final runoff. Look at how quick Maddog was in reciprocating Tainted's vote. I voted Maddog right when the game started, he popped into the thread twice and didn't vote until Tainted voted him. Distancing gone bad?
Obviously it's not impossible, and I'm not a math guy so I can't run the probabilities, but I don't think we should go forward thinking that a 2 mafia D1 showdown was what happened.
Could be an attempt to stay alive, or you could be right.
I am keeping my vote here for now for the additional reason that It also could be they voted for each other as mafia partners and never got a chance to change and we ended up getting lucky with a 2 mafia final runoff. Look at how quick Maddog was in reciprocating Tainted's vote. I voted Maddog right when the game started, he popped into the thread twice and didn't vote until Tainted voted him. Distancing gone bad?
Obviously it's not impossible, and I'm not a math guy so I can't run the probabilities, but I don't think we should go forward thinking that a 2 mafia D1 showdown was what happened.
It does seem unlikely and I am not set on it. Maddog's early day 1 actions are the only reason I'm considering it at all.
As to the part I bolded: That's the crux of the game. What's important? What's not? I need to ask myself what you were thinking when you made this post. We're you truly asking, or are you just trying to blend in? And if I jump down your throat about what you just said or nitpick how you phrased it, there's a good chance I'll be wrong. There's also a good chance I'll jump down your throat just to see how you react. That's the part of the game the burns some people and makes them hate it.
Why is Tainted so quiet? Was there anything behind the fact that Thor checked in late? This early in the game, these things are usually not worth focusing on, but take note.
If JR was dropping breadcrumbs, could this have been it?
Post by Cookin' Mama on Jan 20, 2019 20:53:24 GMT -5
If Maddog were mafia why wouldn't he put up more of a fight when he went out? He just kept saying "I'm town I'm town" over and over. I feel like he'd try to do more to try and save himself.
If Maddog were mafia why wouldn't he put up more of a fight when he went out? He just kept saying "I'm town I'm town" over and over. I feel like he'd try to do more to try and save himself.
Someone mentioned that he mught have just thrown in the towel since he was kinda just thrown into the game
If Maddog were mafia why wouldn't he put up more of a fight when he went out? He just kept saying "I'm town I'm town" over and over. I feel like he'd try to do more to try and save himself.
Someone mentioned that he mught have just thrown in the towel since he was kinda just thrown into the game
And completely screw over his other mafia members?
If Maddog were mafia why wouldn't he put up more of a fight when he went out? He just kept saying "I'm town I'm town" over and over. I feel like he'd try to do more to try and save himself.
I’m not 100% sold on mad dog being mafia, but if he was, what was he suppose to say? He would have to argue that tainted was mafia, and he barely posted.
If Maddog were mafia why wouldn't he put up more of a fight when he went out? He just kept saying "I'm town I'm town" over and over. I feel like he'd try to do more to try and save himself.
I’m not 100% sold on mad dog being mafia, but if he was, what was he suppose to say? He would have to argue that tainted was mafia, and he barely posted.
Yeah I guess you've got a point but I just figured he'd say... something.
Post by potentpotables on Jan 21, 2019 9:48:29 GMT -5
Carini, Jortles, and Thor haven't gotten a vote cast against them yet, and Jaz only had my throwaway D1R1 vote against him. Based on a random sample of 4 of 11 players, the average number of mafia in any group of 4 is like 1.3 isn't it? It's more than 1, that I know.
Post by potentpotables on Jan 21, 2019 9:52:52 GMT -5
JR cast his initial vote on JTR, stayed there until JTR dropped out of the runoff, then cast the tying vote for Maddog (who was then voted off by Thor). Re-reading JR's posts, maybe he was whacked for saying he didn't think Maddog was inspector, and the mere mention of that made mafia think he might be? That would seem to point toward JTR then, possibly as the given name but also possibly as just a lucky coincidence and it freaked them out.
JR cast his initial vote on JTR, stayed there until JTR dropped out of the runoff, then cast the tying vote for Maddog (who was then voted off by Thor). Re-reading JR's posts, maybe he was whacked for saying he didn't think Maddog was inspector, and the mere mention of that made mafia think he might be? That would seem to point toward JTR then, possibly as the given name but also possibly as just a lucky coincidence and it freaked them out.
I had considered that, especially since he made it a point to say that he was considering whether or not he should've stacked, so his vote on JTR was intentional. But then at the end of the round he voted along with JTR, which I don't see him doing if he was Inspector with JTR's name.
JR cast his initial vote on JTR, stayed there until JTR dropped out of the runoff, then cast the tying vote for Maddog (who was then voted off by Thor). Re-reading JR's posts, maybe he was whacked for saying he didn't think Maddog was inspector, and the mere mention of that made mafia think he might be? That would seem to point toward JTR then, possibly as the given name but also possibly as just a lucky coincidence and it freaked them out.
I had considered that, especially since he made it a point to say that he was considering whether or not he should've stacked, so his vote on JTR was intentional. But then at the end of the round he voted along with JTR, which I don't see him doing if he was Inspector with JTR's name.
I agree it's less likely that he had JTR's name and voted with him, but it still could be that he didn't have JTR's name, JTR is mafia all the same, and it freaked mafia out accidentally.
Carini, Jortles, and Thor haven't gotten a vote cast against them yet, and Jaz only had my throwaway D1R1 vote against him. Based on a random sample of 4 of 11 players, the average number of mafia in any group of 4 is like 1.3 isn't it? It's more than 1, that I know.
Just something to keep an eye on.
My initial vote on D1 R1 was against Thor. But like you said it's a throwaway.
Carini, Jortles, and Thor haven't gotten a vote cast against them yet, and Jaz only had my throwaway D1R1 vote against him. Based on a random sample of 4 of 11 players, the average number of mafia in any group of 4 is like 1.3 isn't it? It's more than 1, that I know.
Just something to keep an eye on.
Both Carini and Thor still haven’t voted yet either.
He hasn't gotten a vote yet so I'll put one on him. Kanye and I were thrown into the fire with our first game, now it's your turn!
My first mafia vote - a moment I shall remember forever.
Any reason beyond wanting to gather more info after Potent pointed out that few people haven't been voted for? To be fair I agree with that strategy even if I am on the wrong end of it.
He hasn't gotten a vote yet so I'll put one on him. Kanye and I were thrown into the fire with our first game, now it's your turn!
My first mafia vote - a moment I shall remember forever.
Any reason beyond wanting to gather more info after Potent pointed out that few people haven't been voted for? To be fair I agree with that strategy even if I am on the wrong end of it.
Like I said I'm not too convinced by any of the arguments, including that one. Which is why I didn't end up voting last night. You were part of the group that hadn't had a vote/had throw away votes with are basically one and the same.
Post by Jake Jortles on Jan 21, 2019 12:19:44 GMT -5
I think we are a little too in love with JRs one post explaining the new player concept to JTR. Especially since we have 3 new players in here even if it was a hint. Either way I totally get that its worthwhile to put some pressure on me and see how I react and so forth.
I think we are a little too in love with JRs one post explaining the new player concept to JTR. Especially since we have 3 new players in here even if it was a hint. Either way I totally get that its worthwhile to put some pressure on me and see how I react and so forth.
