Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
something a coached newbie would obviously never do.
Also are you and JTR playing video games in the same room right now?
Lol you’re reaching.
they mentioned playing smash bros together earlier today. Was just going to ask kanye to read JTRs body language for me. Just joking around there though.
Cookin' Mama you say you guessed me because I was quiet? Have you been poking the Zig again? I haven't been quiet this game. Also where on day 1 did I have any interaction with Jortles that would make guessing me make any sense at all?
Carini>>>Jortles>>>JTR
Jaz it should always say I'm online. I keep a tab open on my phone whenever I'm in a game
Lol I know what you meant. Why do you say that he's the third? Show your work.
Oh okay I thought you were for real.
Like I said in the original post Carini and Jortles both voted with with Tainted to vote out maddog and to save Tainted. Also Carini pulled out a weak reason to try and vote for Tainted to try and distance those two from one another. That's my original thoughts. I always thought it was Tainted but I wasn't 100% and my next guess would've been you if for whatever reason Tainted no longer appeared to be mafia to me. Seeing how you've reacted to all of this leads me to you are not mafia. Maybe this is too presumptuous of me. I was excited when I typed what I originally typed.
Cookin' Mama you say you guessed me because I was quiet? Have you been poking the Zig again? I haven't been quiet this game. Also where on day 1 did I have any interaction with Jortles that would make guessing me make any sense at all?
Carini>>>Jortles>>>JTR
Jaz it should always say I'm online. I keep a tab open on my phone whenever I'm in a game
You're right. In D2 you haven't been quite at all and have been talking a whole lot. But I voted based on how you were playing in D1. In D1 you barely talked, especially when the runoffs started. And when you did talk in D1 you weren't saying anything.
Cookin' Mama you say you guessed me because I was quiet? Have you been poking the Zig again? I haven't been quiet this game. Also where on day 1 did I have any interaction with Jortles that would make guessing me make any sense at all?
Carini>>>Jortles>>>JTR
Jaz it should always say I'm online. I keep a tab open on my phone whenever I'm in a game
You're right. In D2 you haven't been quite at all and have been talking a whole lot. But I voted based on how you were playing in D1. In D1 you barely talked, especially when the runoffs started. And when you did talk in D1 you weren't saying anything.
I stated my suspicions of Maddog. Ihis is BS. At no point day 1 was I anywhere near the loweest post counts. Who coached you to say that line?
You're right. In D2 you haven't been quite at all and have been talking a whole lot. But I voted based on how you were playing in D1. In D1 you barely talked, especially when the runoffs started. And when you did talk in D1 you weren't saying anything.
I stated my suspicions of Maddog. Ihis is BS. At no point day 1 was I anywhere near the loweest post counts. Who coached you to say that line?
Like I said, in D1 you said nothing of substance so you could buff up your post counts.
Lol I know what you meant. Why do you say that he's the third? Show your work.
Oh okay I thought you were for real.
Like I said in the original post Carini and Jortles both voted with with Tainted to vote out maddog and to save Tainted. Also Carini pulled out a weak reason to try and vote for Tainted to try and distance those two from one another. That's my original thoughts. I always thought it was Tainted but I wasn't 100% and my next guess would've been you if for whatever reason Tainted no longer appeared to be mafia to me. Seeing how you've reacted to all of this leads me to you are not mafia. Maybe this is too presumptuous of me. I was excited when I typed what I originally typed.
Be careful about being to cocksure about anyone you don't have concrete info on. Sure, Tainted could be the third and would justify a 3-0 split, but there's nothing excluding Maddog/me/Dan/Kanye from being the third just yet either. At least, no one's put forth reasons to rule them out (or they did and I just missed it, which is quite possible).
Like I said in the original post Carini and Jortles both voted with with Tainted to vote out maddog and to save Tainted. Also Carini pulled out a weak reason to try and vote for Tainted to try and distance those two from one another. That's my original thoughts. I always thought it was Tainted but I wasn't 100% and my next guess would've been you if for whatever reason Tainted no longer appeared to be mafia to me. Seeing how you've reacted to all of this leads me to you are not mafia. Maybe this is too presumptuous of me. I was excited when I typed what I originally typed.
Be careful about being to cocksure about anyone you don't have concrete info on. Sure, Tainted could be the third and would justify a 3-0 split, but there's nothing excluding Maddog/me/Dan/Kanye from being the third just yet either. At least, no one's put forth reasons to rule them out (or they did and I just missed it, which is quite possible).
Yeah you're right. On the evidence that I have right now I think the strongest case is against Tainted.
Post by potentpotables on Jan 21, 2019 19:07:57 GMT -5
For a couple of reasons (not the least of which is the design of this game), I'm starting to doubt JTR's reveal. I'm reading through the thread but also trying to make my famous stuffed peppers for dinner so this might come across piecemeal.
My first reservation is that he named Tainted so quickly. Carini's initial D1 vote was for Maddog, then Tainted stacks and throws Maddog into the runoff. Would mafia stack like that in D1R1? Maybe, but it's one hole I'm poking in the reveal.
Second reservation is why he chose to guess Carini. "Carini was quiet" definitely equals mafia, but I'm a post count whore and have been checking it constantly. I've yet to post it because I was among the most active so didn't want to seem like I was driving that convo. But my point here is that, as Carini said, I'm always jumping on him when he's quiet. I didn't think he was extra quiet this game so I didn't mention it. I can't figure out why JTR would guess Carini, and I don't buy his stated reason.
Post by potentpotables on Jan 21, 2019 19:11:08 GMT -5
Another reservation is that I feel like JTR could have capitalized on the fact that Carini and Jortles had no votes against them. That's a persuasive argument for putting people in runoffs, so it comes across as believable in an inspector reveal. Which is why it gives me pause. Not dispositive, but another potential hole.
Yet another reservation is my own personal theory when a mafia member. I always think it makes sense to fake a reveal at this point of the game to see if we flushed out the inspector and got the whack right on N1. *If* JTR is mafia, then this is working like a beaut in confirming their suspicions on the N1 whack. The timing of the fake appeals to me greatly if I were a mafia teammate.
Potent I’m not going to say that impossible, but what’s the other option? Who is mafia then? Obviously JTR but I don’t see how he slots in with an inspector JR.
