Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Post by Jake Jortles on May 22, 2020 20:22:26 GMT -5
Of course Theo is the true dumbass here if hes town, which I cant imagine he is. Im only annoyed at Potent for not reacting perfectly to how dumb our Town is.
Post by Jeremy Fragrance on May 22, 2020 20:23:09 GMT -5
Yeah Potent if you knew I was faking why would you do the same thing again, I could have taken the hit tonight and you and Kanye would both be alive tomorrow.
Yeah Potent if you knew I was faking why would you do the same thing again, I could have taken the hit tonight and you and Kanye would both be alive tomorrow.
because I couldn't imagine that someone would be so stupid to fake again.
STOP FUCKING FAKING AS TOWN. THIS IS A TEAM GAME. YOU CANNOT ACT ON YOUR OWN. FUCK.
Theos fucking mafia man this is his last gasp. To add another layer to the stupidity, if Theo was town trying this move to trick mafia, he should have revealed tomorrow after potentially throwing off the whack.
Inspectors should still guess Theo imo. 0% chance he should make it through Day 5. If hes Town he can wear Mafia 127 on his back like a scarlett letter.
Because I'm confident in the 3rd and don't think Dan was doctor
Just want to say... you have no idea if Dan was Doctor. A 0% chance you have any better thought on that than anyone else. And also your 3rd guess could also be complete bs.
You should have let Day 2 play out a bit before saying this. But I'll play along pre-reveal.
Dan originally expanded the runoff to get Teddy in, then he voted for him later. His post about "mafia being involved" in a bunch of vote switches... can someone interpret that for me? I imagine that triggered Mafia.
I'd also like to keep my two names available for the d3 a and b lynches
Leaving 4 and 5 up to chance but I feel really good about my guess and the people left standing
I have no idea what this means but I dont trust your future guess as much as you do and I dont have enough confidence that Dan wasnt doctor. No way you should go into the night without telling us the name unless Doctor comes out to admit they are alive.
And personally I think doc should come out btw. Either puts us at ease about kanye living through the night or its a fake that may give us the third mafia.
And personally I think doc should come out btw. Either puts us at ease about kanye living through the night or its a fake that may give us the third mafia.
I disagree. If doctor comes out they can just whack him
I'm sorta thinking doctor or not, Mafia may go a completely different direction with the whack, to place doubt on your claim and avoid the double lynch
I'm sorta thinking doctor or not, Mafia may go a completely different direction with the whack, to place doubt on your claim and avoid the double lynch
That's bad for them if doctor stays hidden. Unless they try to guess doctor.
Silver Surfer , what if we lynch Rothric and you guess differently? And hope Danbob wasn't doctor.
I actually love this but would want doctor to show themselves so we have comfort. Kanye gets successfully whacked and we know the third was faking Doctor.
I actually love this but would want doctor to show themselves so we have comfort. Kanye gets successfully whacked and we know the third was faking Doctor.
Spitballing here, but if doctor reveals doesn't it give mafia a whack and rob town of an extra day? If Kanye doesn't survive, we have two names, know Danbob was doctor, and will have to slog through again but Rothric and Theo are the two main suspects.
I think we need to face the facts that Maddog/Rummy probably aren't going to vote and be fine if they are voted off. I think the guess tonight has value. We might want to consider just voting one of them off and moving to the next day.
Unless doc wants to come out... then the plan is solid.
I don't think we should kill rummy or maddog today
I think the only way we can do this is if the doctor stays hidden. If they come out, it gives a target for the whack overnight and there will only be 1 lynch D3, and then you’re dead.
I think the only way we can do this is if the doctor stays hidden. If they come out, it gives a target for the whack overnight and there will only be 1 lynch D3, and then you’re dead.
What if Dan was the doctor? Are you that confident to risk it?
I think it's best to lynch someone here that isn't rummy or maddog
Seems like you’re committed to this. I’m the doctor.
This is every post that mentioned doctor on D2 with the last one being Theo's fake. There is absolutely no reason to fake this here. I wasn't going to come out and everybody would have thought Dan was doctor, and at best the mafia would have had a 20% chance of guessing correctly, and that's if they let the claimed inspector live.
Faking doctor is a terrible strategy as town, we need to fucking stop it.
STOP FUCKING FAKING AS TOWN. THIS IS A TEAM GAME. YOU CANNOT ACT ON YOUR OWN. FUCK.
Theos fucking mafia man this is his last gasp. To add another layer to the stupidity, if Theo was town trying this move to trick mafia, he should have revealed tomorrow after potentially throwing off the whack.
Inspectors should still guess Theo imo. 0% chance he should make it through Day 5. If hes Town he can wear Mafia 127 on his back like a scarlett letter.
Yeah I don't know why i did what I did. I should have waited until tomorrow to post that I'm faking. It probably doesn't help that I'm high right now lol. Sorry town
Post by Jake Jortles on May 22, 2020 20:35:16 GMT -5
I want everyone to think back to pre reveal.
We were asking Doc to come out so Inspector could feel comfortable going into the night while trying a unique strategy.
We are to believe that Theo, as Town, wanted to give everyone a false sense of belief that we had a living Doctor. So if Dan was actual Doctor, he may have sabotaged the entire game.
Hes fucking Mafia. He miscalculated. Lets just end the fucking game. Inspectors should guess him, then we wipe out him and the two Inspectors. Game over Town win.
We were asking Doc to come out so Inspector could feel comfortable going into the night while trying a unique strategy.
We are to believe that Theo, as Town, wanted to give everyone a false sense of belief that we had a living Doctor. So if Dan was actual Doctor, he may have sabotaged the entire game.
Hes fucking Mafia. He miscalculated. Lets just end the fucking game. Inspectors should guess him, then we wipe out him and the two Inspectors. Game over Town win.
Would a mafia Kanye or mafia Maddog let me do this?
What is the advantage to faking doctor as town AFTER the inspector has revealed?
The real doctor, whether hidden or revealed, will still provide their real protection to the inspector. They can't save the inspector twice. That's it and then the inspector is whacked the next night.
I can see the strategy for faking as town BEFORE the inspector reveal. There's a solid chance the real doctor doesn't yet know the inspector and doesn't use their protection on them. And you in turn, draw the mafia's whack away from the real inspector/doctor.
But what good is it after the inspector has revealed?
Am I missing something in the rule play for doctor?
What is the advantage to faking doctor as town AFTER the inspector has revealed?
The real doctor, whether hidden or revealed, will still provide their real protection to the inspector. They can't save the inspector twice. That's it and then the inspector is whacked the next night.
I can see the strategy for faking as town BEFORE the inspector reveal. There's a solid chance the real doctor doesn't yet know the inspector and doesn't use their protection on them. And you in turn, draw the mafia's whack away from the real inspector/doctor.
But what good is it after the inspector has revealed?
Am I missing something in the rule play for doctor?
I think if Theo is faking as town then potent definitely shouldn't have come out. But since he did, Theo definitely shouldn't have admitted to faking.
Post by Silver Surfer on May 22, 2020 20:55:27 GMT -5
What are the fucking odds man wtf
A) potent and I likely have the same roles as last game B) a townie potential faked doctor C) at least 2 of my mafia teammates from within the last like 4 games is mafia again
What is the advantage to faking doctor as town AFTER the inspector has revealed?
The real doctor, whether hidden or revealed, will still provide their real protection to the inspector. They can't save the inspector twice. That's it and then the inspector is whacked the next night.
I can see the strategy for faking as town BEFORE the inspector reveal. There's a solid chance the real doctor doesn't yet know the inspector and doesn't use their protection on them. And you in turn, draw the mafia's whack away from the real inspector/doctor.
But what good is it after the inspector has revealed?
Am I missing something in the rule play for doctor?
I think if Theo is faking as town then potent definitely shouldn't have come out. But since he did, Theo definitely shouldn't have admitted to faking.
You are asking an impossible thing - how would I know if he was faking as town or mafia? I just know he's faking and have to make a judgment based on the reactions to him.
Since the inspector had already revealed it would have benefitted the town for no doctor claim.
In fact, Theo's fake insures that mafia gets a whack tonight and doesn't face two days in a row. An incomprehensibly bad move if he's town.
I think if Theo is faking as town then potent definitely shouldn't have come out. But since he did, Theo definitely shouldn't have admitted to faking.
You are asking an impossible thing - how would I know if he was faking as town or mafia? I just know he's faking and have to make a judgment based on the reactions to him.
Since the inspector had already revealed it would have benefitted the town for no doctor claim.
In fact, Theo's fake insures that mafia gets a whack tonight and doesn't face two days in a row. An incomprehensibly bad move if he's town.
I know you're right. I'm just bummed we might be screwed by a townie faking as doctor again.
We were asking Doc to come out so Inspector could feel comfortable going into the night while trying a unique strategy.
We are to believe that Theo, as Town, wanted to give everyone a false sense of belief that we had a living Doctor. So if Dan was actual Doctor, he may have sabotaged the entire game.
Hes fucking Mafia. He miscalculated. Lets just end the fucking game. Inspectors should guess him, then we wipe out him and the two Inspectors. Game over Town win.
Would a mafia Kanye or mafia Maddog let me do this?
Ive definitely thought about how your teammates would be very upset with this move. But I think there is a chance there was a false sense of confidence that Dan was Doc.
I think the only way to guarantee a day 5 is to guess one of you or potent so hopefully neither of you are town faking doctor, AGAIN
Fine. I'm faking as town. We're in a similar situation to last game, and I really don't want you to waste your guess on me. I thought I could make tonights whack very difficult for mafia by hopefully getting them to whack me, the fake doctor, or you, as Potent would be on you, giving us 2 lynches tomorrow. Maddog's reveal messed this all up anyways. Now that I have to do this, Potent will be whacked tonight, and there will be 1 lynch tomorrow. Sorry town, I really thought it would be helpful this time. Again, as I said, faking as mafia is completely stupid right now, because it's exposing the third mafia when the other two mafia are already out there in the open.
Even if Potent hadn't revealed, your plan still would not have worked. Mafia would have whacked you, and we'd still just have 1 lynch tomorrow.
In order for us to have 2 lynches tomorrow, the doctor's protection must be used. The way this happens in this case is if mafia use their whack on Kanye, and the real doctor (Potent) uses his protection on Kanye. I guess they could take a wild guess if they really thought someone else was the doctor, but it would be a big gamble.
In fact, if we followed your plan, it then casts all kind of doubt on Potent when he does finally reveal the next day. All it does is confuse the town and help mafia.
Or I'll ask again, am I missing how the doctor role works? This is only my second game with one. To get two lynches, the mafia's whack HAS to be blocked by the doctor's protection, right?
I do believe you're town faking. I can't see mafia outing their third unless they just wanted the game over?
