Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Post by piggy pablo on Jun 4, 2021 17:39:10 GMT -5
Yeah I think there's too much of that narrative getting pushed, in a way that smells funny to me. There were only four Rummy voters. We really think all three Mafia were on her, and there weren't any in the seven Maddog voters?
Yeah I think there's too much of that narrative getting pushed, in a way that smells funny to me. There were only four Rummy voters. We really think all three Mafia were on her, and there weren't any in the seven Maddog voters?
Personally yes, but I don’t discount the idea kpo could’ve been maf
Jortles, this would be the perfect game to run your strat back from a few games ago with me and Dan. If it's not Dan/Jorts/Silv, you guys are acting awfully coincidentally.
piggy pabloJazRummy 500 currently I don't see a way with this to make a runoff and make another choose, since Pablo and Jaz are the other options. But it seems like you guys, Pablo and Jaz, believe Silv and therefore think Jorts is cleared. Is there any way out of this? Or do we just need to capitulate. Pablo seemed town to me but if you don't want to fight it then we might as well end it.
Trying to recall my strat from a few games ago. Remind me plz
Defending each other in the thread, playing the whole thing on the nose. I almost want it to be you/Silv/Dan because it will have been beautifully played.
Yeah because I felt it important to only have one of those variables left and it made sense to me that one Mafia member might've tried to sow doubt about my reveal
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Trying to recall my strat from a few games ago. Remind me plz
Defending each other in the thread, playing the whole thing on the nose. I almost want it to be you/Silv/Dan because it will have been beautifully played.
oh right lol. Not happening here. Just going along with an uncontested reveal and hoping for the best. Will mentally check back in if it gets to d5
Defending each other in the thread, playing the whole thing on the nose. I almost want it to be you/Silv/Dan because it will have been beautifully played.
oh right lol. Not happening here. Just going along with an uncontested reveal and hoping for the best. Will mentally check back in if it gets to d5
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Fr though if Maddog was Mafia, I think Jortles and KPO both look like good suspects for their pile-on onto him. Sometimes it's more beneficial to just cut your losses - though unintentional, this worked for Mafia last game.
Really what this game hinges on is whether or not Mafia aced the N1 whack, and whether the things that Theo said fit with the pieces that remain if if he was indeed Inspector. I'm willing to examine the Silver as Mafia angle, but I think it's the less likely option rn.
Post by potentpotables on Jun 4, 2021 18:40:21 GMT -5
Having played almost literally half of the games on inforoo in the past, not much surprises me anymore. Could I be wrong and be a big idiot for not believing Silv? Absolutely. Did I question Maddog last game? You betcha.
Silver guessing Rummy N2 when he's been on and on about Rummy voters...that surprised me.
I can't stress this enough. Silver was talking about Rummy voters D2 (a theory I would agree with in general). He's been talking Rummy voters D3.
It is absolutely flummoxing in that context that he wouldn't ask about a Rummy voter.
I already explained why I did.
i think it bothers me less that you guessed me and more the way you presented it as soon as Night ended.
You were like “good news bad news” then went onto clarify that I’m not mafia and that we should have the math to win.
As inspector shouldn’t you have prefaced with “I get people are going to think this was a weird choice for my guess, but let me explain upfront the reasoning behind it.”
I know this is a nuance but to me it stuck out as weird to start out with “good news bad news!!”
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
i think it bothers me less that you guessed me and more the way you presented it as soon as Night ended.
You were like “good news bad news” then went onto clarify that I’m not mafia and that we should have the math to win.
As inspector shouldn’t you have prefaced with “I get people are going to think this was a weird choice for my guess, but let me explain upfront the reasoning behind it.”
I know this is a nuance but to me it stuck out as weird to start out with “good news bad news!!”
i think it bothers me less that you guessed me and more the way you presented it as soon as Night ended.
You were like “good news bad news” then went onto clarify that I’m not mafia and that we should have the math to win.
As inspector shouldn’t you have prefaced with “I get people are going to think this was a weird choice for my guess, but let me explain upfront the reasoning behind it.”
I know this is a nuance but to me it stuck out as weird to start out with “good news bad news!!”
Really?
look, I’ve really gone back and forth on whether to believe you. So I am trying to look at each detail, and for whatever reason that one stands out.
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
If silver is faking, this is the work of Danny/Jostles/Silv trio, without a doubt.
Also if MD isn’t mafia at long last but being framed as such after his death, on the one game recently where he was actually town, I bet he’s having an fit over on the sidelines rn
If MD wasn't Mafia, that would make Theo inspector. But I don't really like the things Theo said point to this. Some things pointed to Jortles but he also mentioned that he didn't think Jortles needed to proceed into a runoff. So if he was Inspector he didn't have Jortles' name imo.
If silver is faking, this is the work of Danny/Jostles/Silv trio, without a doubt.
Also if MD isn’t mafia at long last but being framed as such after his death, on the one game recently where he was actually town, I bet he’s having an fit over on the sidelines rn
If MD wasn't Mafia, that would make Theo inspector. But I don't really like the things Theo said point to this. Some things pointed to Jortles but he also mentioned that he didn't think Jortles needed to proceed into a runoff. So if he was Inspector he didn't have Jortles' name imo.
Point being I don't think the game ends tonight.
fair. But do you also agree then that in this same line of logic, it shouldn’t matter the order?
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Bad news is I kinda went rogue and guessed Rumdawg. She's town.
Good news- we've won! Here's why-
D3a- Teddy D3b- Jaz N3- Me D4- Pablo
And then if that doesn't end the game we should at least get to day 5 with two confirmed townies
N4- Rummy/Potent/Jortles D5- 2 of Rummy/Potent/Jortles vs unknown dan
But here's the thing. Even if you are Inspector, only plays out if you're the N3 whack. Given that would indeed end the game for the Mafia because it would confirm you as Inspector, it stands to reason that you won't be the N3 whack. Meaning the reason the game is still going is because they plan on keeping you alive. Leaving our D5 as a named townie, an Unknown, and you.
So, you didn't hand us the game in the way that you think.
And I don't wanna hear from anyone that I'm giving Mafia ideas. If Silver is inspector there's no way they didn't already start thinking about this.
This all also means that the door is still open for Silver to be Mafia, with a D5 of him, one of me/pablo/dan, and one of rummy/potent.
For myself I'll say I'm grateful that Potent is town, because it means I can trust him and he seems to be very good at reading Rummy. So if he thinks she's undeniably Town regardless of Silver's role, I'm willing to outsource my opinion on Rummy to him for that one just to eliminate thinking about Silver/Rummy options.
