Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Post by handgunhipster on Jun 26, 2009 14:42:39 GMT -5
I null my vote.
I don't know why the focus on Bacon.
I think if Ian was mafia, as our 'Inspector' is claiming.. maybe the mafia realized that they couldn't save him and voted him out just to make themselves not look obvious. It's been done before, and I think focusing on people who didn't vote for Ian, or voted with him, isn't the route to go. I'm not mafia, and apparently I voted with Ian. It meant nothing.
Post by handgunhipster on Jun 26, 2009 14:52:52 GMT -5
I vote Rooconteur.
I don't believe Kdogg is on the right track. He listed Higgi, EAP, and myself as his suspects. He was wrong about Higgi, he says. I know he's wrong about me. EAP seems angry enough to be a townsperson.
I've been at work all day ( where Inforoo is banned) and was afraid I'd come back to find I was the tie-breaking vote. I'm not really convinced of Ian's guilt, but my the numbers are already in so I guess I'll go with the crowd.
I have a sneaking suspicion who two of the mafia are. I can't prove it yet but if it's who I'm thinking then we have two of the sneakiest players I've seen in a while as mafia ( or so I've heard, remember I've never played before!).
kdogg...i'm not necessarily calling you out at this point. i still think you're more than likely the most important asset to us right now. but at the same time...what did cajun mean?! did he know something and not have enough time to tell us?
and if by some chance kdogg IS lying...he's said that higgi is innocent. what if that's all a rouse and we're falling for it?
like i said...i'm confused, and am not pointing fingers at anyone...just trying to come up with several theories before i vote.
I do not know what the right path is. I only know one wrong potential path.
I think there's something to what you said, Handgun... Higgi voted with Ian both times, and that didn't make him guilty.
Here's why I'm looking at Bacon: He & Ian did reciprocal voting for one another in the first round - two Mafia voting one another in the first round is not uncommon. They just weren't expecting me to have a hunch about Ian and jump into the fray. Bacon was also quick to assert that Cajun was the Inspector. That also seems suspicious to me. A Mafia would want Townspeople to believe there's no Inspector to listen to. Right?
I've been at work all day ( where Inforoo is banned) and was afraid I'd come back to find I was the tie-breaking vote. I'm not really convinced of Ian's guilt, but my the numbers are already in so I guess I'll go with the crowd.
I have a sneaking suspicion who two of the mafia are. I can't prove it yet but if it's who I'm thinking then we have two of the sneakiest players I've seen in a while as mafia ( or so I've heard, remember I've never played before!).
kdogg...i'm not necessarily calling you out at this point. i still think you're more than likely the most important asset to us right now. but at the same time...what did cajun mean?! did he know something and not have enough time to tell us?
and if by some chance kdogg IS lying...he's said that higgi is innocent. what if that's all a rouse and we're falling for it?
like i said...i'm confused, and am not pointing fingers at anyone...just trying to come up with several theories before i vote.
I'm also confused by this. Kdogg has outed himself after 1 round. He's going to get killed by the mafia tonight, if he's the Inspector and he won't be able to give us any other information.
kdogg, why the decision to out yourself so early? I wasn't insisting you were mafia when you came out as Inspector, I was saying you could be a confused townsperson. I don't understand how making it known you're the Inspector this early benefits the townspeople.
since i haven't officially stated it yet, I'm a townsperson..
I am also confused, and have a gut feeling that something fishy is going on here.. I find it interesting that Handgun, Hippie and Kdogg all nulled their votes almost simultaneously after being so confident of her guilt...
since i haven't officially stated it yet, I'm a townsperson..
I am also confused, and have a gut feeling that something fishy is going on here.. I find it interesting that Handgun, Hippie and Kdogg all nulled their votes almost simultaneously after being so confident of her guilt...
and i find it interesting that you were so adamant we were "on the right track" with eap before. what makes you so sure of it?
i nulled my vote because, as i've stated already, i feel kdogg is our best asset at this point. i could be wrong, but seeing as how its only the 2nd round, its the most i have to go on. i think he made a good point that it was obvious the mafia were supporting the kill with eap, therefore we should switch. how does that not make sense?
and again...i am simply confused at this point. but i AM a townsperson.
on the right track because Kdogg has all but outed himself as the inspector, and by him claiming that I am innocent gave credibility to his statements, in my mind, because I am indeed innocent.
That's not to say he could be trying to just get me on his side, I mean afterall, he did call me a 'cool guy' and that is a definite first.
Well of course Mafia are going to jump on the bandwagon, as it's an easy cover for them, and now that it was clearly stated that we know this fact, wouldn't you think they will be extra careful with vote placement from here on out.. I feel as if nulling votes and basically telling the mafia what NOT to do is a mistake.. how does THAT not make sense? ;D
since i haven't officially stated it yet, I'm a townsperson..
I am also confused, and have a gut feeling that something fishy is going on here.. I find it interesting that Handgun, Hippie and Kdogg all nulled their votes almost simultaneously after being so confident of her guilt...
I felt the same way... It was almost like vote stacking, but reversed. I am beyond confused. At this point we need to keep every option open. Cajun being inspector and was given Kdogg's name. Or Kdogg is our inspector and was given Ian's name and ask about Higgi's innocent. Or Kdogg and Higgi could be working together.
Post by GratefulHippie on Jun 26, 2009 15:25:59 GMT -5
what do you mean telling them what NOT to do? you've got me more confused than the game.
you completely proved my point. it IS an easy cover for them to vote for someone who they OBVIOUSLY would like to see dead. so why then would we want to continue with eap's death if we KNOW it would help the mafia?
Post by handgunhipster on Jun 26, 2009 15:27:49 GMT -5
Higgi, I was confused about EAP-- but I didn't vote for her because I wanted to let her speak.
At the point that she finally said something, my vote didn't matter anyway because so many people had voted for her. I gladly nulled my vote when I saw how frustrated she was, because I've been in that same position with being a townsperson and everyone ganging up on me. I'm trusting Kdogg, but we're barking up the wrong tree.
Why not look at the quiet ones..? The main posts have been Hippie, Higgi, myself and Kdogg. We're assuming 3 if not all 4 of these are innocent.
on the right track because Kdogg has all but outed himself as the inspector, and by him claiming that I am innocent gave credibility to his statements, in my mind, because I am indeed innocent.
We saw this last game, higgi. He could be Mafia trying to earn your trust. Chief did it to Bacon, I am not saying he is but it isn't enough for me to trust someone over!
I sense you are afraid of her because she made some valid points against you and you don't want any attention directed in your way
I vote KDiggity
Not wanting attention my way does not necessarily mean that I am guilty. I am not afraid of Handgun, per se... I'm just not sure about her yet.
I also vote EAP.
with next to NO explanation at all, Kdogg voted EAP... That led me to believe that he knew something we didn't..
also it's not necessarily Mafia's approval if they already know that EAP is going down, they have no choice but to follow the masses. That particular instance could easily fit that description.
I will be honest in saying that I am not sure of much, but I am, however, "taking no left turn unstoned," hehe, thanks Roo.
Post by GratefulHippie on Jun 26, 2009 15:51:22 GMT -5
ok sorry...i can't use the internet correctly today apparently...
kdogg's theory about bacon is what makes the most sense to me at this point. especially his point about bacon calling out cajun as inspector. that would make things easier on mafia if we thought our inspector was dead.
now higgi...you do bring up a good point about mafia not having a choice in the matter...hadn't thought of it that way. but if you were certain about kdogg enough to follow his lead with eap in the first place, couldn't we be just as certain enough to NOT vote for her if kdogg has changed his tune?
Post by Fishing Maniac on Jun 26, 2009 16:04:24 GMT -5
You were all very close to having this round done before the weekend. If there isn't a completed vote in the next hour voting will remain open until Monday.
Post by GratefulHippie on Jun 26, 2009 16:10:09 GMT -5
well, while i think higgi raises a good point, i'm going to have to vote for bacon right now. IMO it's the best theory so far, AND eap seems pretty innocent at this point considering EVERYONE voted for her.
