Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Post by awolfatthedoor on Aug 15, 2009 15:30:06 GMT -5
Oh and hippie "the plan" is jen is inspector and strum and hgh are guilty. Which everyone knows at this point btw roo. I was just saying I was going to vote with strum to try and get the third mafia member out to try and save strum and reveal himself.
I am going to go back at sometime and over analyze, but I fear that this will only lead me to nothing because the only remaining mafia has been quiet this game. I'm afraid bek may be the third mafia, that or roo just has me really confused.
Post by rooconteur on Aug 15, 2009 16:27:43 GMT -5
Forgive me for guessing right on hgh. I came to my conclusions based on w ho I thought was not mafia (the most frequenst posters). Remember I thot strum was innocent. Maybe I came across as adamant against hgh, but my strategy is to come up with a theory and pursue it hard until proven other wise. Hippie and higgi were just as positive eachother was giulty.
Also when higgi suggsted I was inspector, jen was the 1st person to warn him not to jump to any conslusions. At that point, I voted hgh and told myself if jen follows immediately (which she did) my guesses were probably too. I think presenting arguments w confidence is more persuaive for the townies. Also maybe I got a little lucky, I call it skill .
Post by rooconteur on Aug 15, 2009 16:37:10 GMT -5
Forgive me for guessing right on hgh. I came to my conclusions based on w ho I thought was not mafia (the most frequenst posters). Remember I thot strum was innocent. Maybe I came across as adamant against hgh, but my strategy is to come up with a theory and pursue it hard until proven other wise. Hippie and higgi were just as positive eachother was giulty.
Also when higgi suggsted I was inspector, jen was the 1st person to warn him not to jump to any conslusions. At that point, I voted hgh and told myself if jen follows immediately (which she did) my guesses were probably too. I think presenting arguments w confidence is more persuaive for the townies. Also maybe I got a little lucky, I call it skill .
Also when higgi suggsted I was inspector, jen was the 1st person to warn him not to jump to any conslusions. At that point, I voted hgh and told myself if jen follows immediately (which she did) my guesses were probably too. I think presenting arguments w confidence is more persuaive for the townies. Also maybe I got a little lucky, I call it skill .
this does make a lot of sense. forgive me if you've already stated it, but what is your reasoning again for voting wolf?
at this point, i still think bek is suspicious, but i don't discount her being busy on account of the crap-ass job market right now. her being very sure about voting you, though, makes me think she's been quiet for more reasons than just the job loss.
so, right now...i'd still say bek or wolf is our best choice.
Also when higgi suggsted I was inspector, jen was the 1st person to warn him not to jump to any conslusions. At that point, I voted hgh and told myself if jen follows immediately (which she did) my guesses were probably too. I think presenting arguments w confidence is more persuaive for the townies. Also maybe I got a little lucky, I call it skill .
Yeah that makes sense if jen was our inspector. But it would also make sense if you and jen were working together.
I told you guys why I haven't been so active. I might not have said much but when I do say something I feel that it has been of value, not just thread litter. Did you ever think that maybe I have a substantial amount of posts and maybe you all just talk too much? I think I even said something like that a few pages ago...
and then the next round I voted for strum right off the bat and stuck with that. If I was mafia wouldn't have helped their defense even just a teeny bit?
I am about 75% sure that jen was our inspector and strum and hgh were mafia but I guess I just been trying to be uber objective this game because last game I rallied behind NBF and her and kelaroo led me and the remaining townspeople straight to defeat.. I am just saying WHAT IF we actually have two mafia left, not one.
It was only after strum's death that I got to thinking it was all too easy and I might not be so easily fooled like I was last time.
That's why I voted for roo, I just think it is better to be safe than sorry. I said I was subject to changing that if someone could come up with a better solution but I haven't really seen one yet. Maybe I'm misguided, maybe I'm over analytical, maybe I'm wrong but I am def innocent and it just feels silly to me that I am having to defend that now when I have done nothing but help you guys.
Post by GratefulHippie on Aug 15, 2009 18:41:21 GMT -5
bek, there's really no reason to get so defensive. if you're just as confused as us, why are you getting so angry just because we took your name into account? your name has barely even been mentioned until now, and it's only because we're down to the wire, and i think it's necessary to look at all angles. i've had to spend the entire game defending myself, so i think if anyone, i have more reason to be annoyed than you.
in any case, you are not even one of my top "most wanted" peeps. however, i don't think roo is guilty. maybe I'M the one who's misguided, but he makes some good points. and sometimes people just make good guesses...strum did in the all-star game and it won it for the townspeople.
in fact, i'm still leaning towards wolf, but something in my gut is worried that higgi is fooling us all again. maybe that's just because i've had to try so hard to prove my innocence to him, or because he's been sneaky in the past.
mostly i just don't want to end up looking stupid and killing us all off
Post by ☮ superbek ☮ on Aug 15, 2009 18:53:05 GMT -5
^^uh... I wasn't angry or aspiring to be overly defensive at all. I logged in and there were questions as to my innocence and imo I answered them appropriately with facts that prove my innocence. I think anyone would have done that, no? Sorry if it came across the wrong way.
edit: and roo why do you always vote and then explain why hours later? I'm sorry, it all just seems kinda suspicious and it continues to raise that little bit of doubt in my mind. I really want to trust you 100% but like hippie said, it really is down to the wire.
which made me think of this (a little something to lighten the mood around here):
Post by GratefulHippie on Aug 15, 2009 19:01:23 GMT -5
yes, i would have done that, and HAVE done that the whole game thanks to mr. higgi. it just came off to me like you thought it was a bad idea to even take your name into account. i for one think everyone is suspicious right now, honestly. i'm so confused by all the talk with strum a few pages back that i know either roo or strum is sitting back laughing at all this
Post by awolfatthedoor on Aug 15, 2009 20:33:29 GMT -5
I'm happy to answer questions if people would like to pose them to me. Because I would much rather there be discussion than I just get killed off just because. I guess if there is a consensus I'm guilty that is fine, but that means townspeople only would have one chance to get the guilty party(next round).
It may be wrong to say I'm confused, but I am. It seems in my mind that I really don't have a solid reason to suspect anyone. Roo I guess I understand what you are saying about the HGH thing. At the time to me it just seemed suspicious because you didn't ever really give a reason as to why, then jen came out so it was proven your guess was right.
Hippie I am most inclined to believe. Idk why but since the beginning I haven't really thought she was mafia except for a second or two.
Bek, to be honest, I really don't have any feelings either way. I just brought your name up because we really don't know anything for sure at this point. And to be honest I don't think you would have defended strum because that would clearly bring you into question, if you were the last mafia. I pretty much gave the last mafia member to bite on saving strum, but no one did. But honestly the only reason I'm leaning you is I am believing everyone else's innocence through their posts. Like I said with you I am not leaning mafia or tp, so that is why I think that you would be the most likely to be guilty. Hopefully this makes sense to everyone. I'm not really saying your guilty or anything, because I would vote for you if I thought I was on to something. I'm just saying I think everyone else is innocent.
Higgi you. are. still. sneaky. But I'm inclined to believe you, but once again it's more of a feeling thing.
edit: and roo why do you always vote and then explain why hours later? I'm sorry, it all just seems kinda suspicious and it continues to raise that little bit of doubt in my mind. I really want to trust you 100% but like hippie said, it really is down to the wire.
usually because i can only access inforoo from my phone bc im at work. i can follow along if i have some down time, but cant be posting full length posts into my phone. if i feel the voting is down to the wire, and might close before i get home, i will change my vote if i think its the right thing to do. last night i voted on I84 in connecticut still spun out from the phish show. a long post was probably a bad idea
and sometimes people just make good guesses...strum did in the all-star game and it won it for the townspeople.
I'd just like to momentarily rise from the dead to say there was no lucky guessing whatsoever on my part. I had solid rationale which was made public before my votes every single time, thank you
6/18: Phish in Hartford 6/25: Phish in Camden 7/2-7/4: Nateva 7/17: God Street Wine at Irving Plaza 7/23-7/25: String Cheese at Red Rocks!! 8/17-8/18: Phish at Jones Beach 9/3: Rush at PNC
This Bonnaroo lineup is in dire need of some Rush.
. 
