Mafia 44 Signups!

Probably. that's why i mentioned the bevies first.

This is Coffee County Sheriff dept., Dexter Lowery is on the case finding some Mafia. Screw arrests, its strap down to a table and break out the OJ knife set.

Dexter Jr, glad to see you, no vote?

Captain FM, I hear you about the late voting. Normally that does not mean a lot to me(who votes first and who votes last being mafia or not?), but these are very late in voting. I think you might be right, that we have a mafia in the run-off (Bonzai or Duddits) and one of the late voters are Mafia as well.
So I feel safe in saying, Your move Mafia.

Duddits - 4
Bonzai - 4

Phi >>> Duddits >>> ?
Bonzai >>> Duddits
rdk >>> bonzai
Duddits >>> Bonzai
Scrog>>>Duddits
FawnMart >> Bonzai >> Duddits
krunchy>>>bonzai
Abra>>Bonazi
LD>>>Duddits

Left To Vote:
Phi

Fawn, I'm convinced that there are 5 or 6 mafia this game. I'm feeling pretty confident about there being at least 2 mafia in your list above, but I've had a hard time figuring out who. I've not been able to sit down and read this entire thread, or do anything else for that matter, for more than 5 minutes without being interrupted. I don't believe today will be any better since I have a kid who woke up this morning with a stomach virus.

I'm hoping we haven't lost our inspector already. You're right, if we have we're screwed. Also, I'm not mafia, although I wish I could get the role so I could finally play with some info and direction!

Phi >>> Duddits

Well, if Inspector is dead and we do not get this right, we will be up the creek with out a paddle. My vote for Duddits was because at that time Bonazi had three votes and Duddits had one. I was not happy or comfortable with that, but this is making me uneasy as well.
FM, you had posted


I agree with this, there are not 3 Mafia in that list, which would mean either Phi, LD, or I am Mafia or maybe 2 of us are. I know I am not and now I find these two putting votes on the same person. That concerns me. When I have a hunch about LD(he became very defensive earlier this round) and wild n crazy voter Phi, both casting the last votes for the same person and neither giving an answer to why they voted for Duddits. I could be wrong, but I feel something fishy here and when it smells like fish, Mafia must be close by. Duddits I am not saying you are not Mafia and Bonzai is a townie, I just am having a weird feeling about this. I would like some input from KK and RDK on this. for now,


Scrog>>>Duddits>>>Null

Duddits - 4
Bonzai - 4

Phi >>> Duddits >>> Duddits
Bonzai >>> Duddits
rdk >>> bonzai
Duddits >>> Bonzai
Scrog>>>Duddits>>>Null
FawnMart >> Bonzai >> Duddits
krunchy>>>bonzai
Abra>>Bonazi
LD>>>Duddits

Left To Vote:
Scrog

Should I change my vote?

Bonzai, you gave two reason why you voted stacked for Duddits.
A. it was the only thing that has stood out to me so far
B. I wanted to get a vote in

Jan 4, 2012 7:56:30 GMT -5 bonzai said:

I did see and congrats, Duddits!! I was going to say something on here (either in here or the Yay thread), but I didn't know if there was a reason why you hadn't mentioned it. So I kept my mouth shut!
I didn't vote for you because you were quiet, but because you were quiet and then slid in with a vote and only a few words. Not saying that you ARE mafia, but I wanted to get a vote in before I was the last to vote.
And Scrog, yes it stacked the votes, but A. it was the only thing that has stood out to me so far and I was planning to vote for him before I saw Phi's post- I saw that it was a stack, but why would I vote for someone 100% random, when I feel a little suspicious of another person? It's not like it's a 52 card pickup like the first round usually is. And B. Like I just said, I wanted to get a vote in, even if it changes- and there is a good chance it will)

B, I can understand that, but A, "the only thing that has stood out so far?" what about Phi's vote stack on me. Duddits even quoted you as his reason for voting for Phi.

and back to B. When Phi's vote was intriguing to you, why did you not vote then if you just, "wanted to get a vote in before I was the last to vote", why did you not vote when you were "intrigued by Phi's vote stack". you speak about how Phi gave no explanation with his vote, but you also say Duddits using "only a few words" as a reason to vote for him. It seems you say these things about Phi's vote stack and then you vote for Duddits and use the same reasons as why you voted for Duddits.
I am not sure if this was planned or not, but I see it like mt old football coach use to say, it is always the second one. What he meant, in the eyes of the ref, 'the first may be suspicious, but the second one is guilty'. meaning after the whistle, and there is an extra push or a late hit, do not retaliate, hit them back, because the second one is always the one that gets a flag. I think that applies here. Bonazi waited until someone stack on Phi, then she voted for them and called out their vote stack as strange(which it is), but yet not do the same towards Phi.
Also, Duddits offered a way out, if you changed your vote he would change his to Phi, but you did not go for that. I evened offer to have a 3-way with you, which you said you would not mind, but yet failed to follow up.
I think Mafia have a vote buried in Bonazi, a vote for her as a way to distance themselves.

LD you do not have to change your vote, because I am.


Scrog>>>Duddits>>>Bonzai

Also, just a heads up, I am traveling to Atlanta today for business and won't be back until Tuesday evening. I will only be able to check this thread in the evenings so I will be very MIA for the next few days.

Scroggie - If you are Mafia, you are playing it brilliantly!

Your new constructive well thought out playing style is infomative and provides good food for thought. You may be manipulating us all, but kudo's to you if you are. Your last post gave me a lot to think about.

To the quiet ones - Yes sharing theories can get you killed off by the mafia if your getting a little too close. But at least as a townie if you go out sharing your thoughts, you might have said something that will lead the townies to the win.

Brings me back to why Omar? He had one vote - agreeing to be dudits VP and voted for duddits. He was extremely quiet, and so was RDK - who stacked from the get go. Of the two RDK was much more likely to be a mafia target - but they whacked Omar. He's only played one game, as mafia. Scrog - if you are setting Bonzai up, awesome well thought out job. I had not thought about the connection of Bonzai being Mafia with Omar last round. IF Bonzai is mafia, I can see where she would want Omar gone because he may have been the inspector, and might recognize tactics used in the last game. (Stuff mafia peeps talk about behind the scenes.)

This game makes me crazy(er).

FM, you are right, if I am Mafia, I have some big Mafia cojones. I could be wrong about Bonzai, but I do not think I am. I have been known to jump on people, like a bulldog, with only a little bit of evidence. I have done that in past games, so if my "constructive well thought out playing style" seems new, it is because it is, I want to win.
Bonzai, I read your words. and I quoted you. Sorry, if I am wrong, but what else do I have to go on?

Bonzai got taken out of the game:



Day 2 has ended, Night 2 has begun. Inspector, PM me your guess. Mafia, PM me your whack.