Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Looking back to day 1, the only person I'm pretty sure is town at this point is potent. Disregard his rookie "it's day 3, inspector should come out", and other minor hiccups, I do believe he's got the towns best interest in mind. Part of the reason I've cooled suspicions on him is looking back before the day 1 mass exodeus from potent (which at the time I felt could have been a mafia power move), you look at who moved their votes away from him (SFA, Sleepy, Rothric, Phi), two of those ppl got whacked, leaving Sleepy and Rothric. For sleepy to be mafia, he'd have to have a huge set of nuts on him to swing the vote at the last second like that, unless Rothric was mafia as well, and sleepy wanted to save him, which would be foolish as fuck, because this clearly would tie them together. Not a smart move on day one, no less. If sleepy and Rothric were both mafia, they'd let Rothric die and cut their losses. If sleepy were mafia and jaz nor Rothric were, why would sleepy put himself out there like that. This leads me to think sleepy is more town than mafia, but maybe that's how he'd hope ppl would think, I dunno.
Anyway, this leaves Tainted, LD, and EAP. I'm not sure which way to go just yet. And since we have time, I'm not rushing anything just yet.
If sleepy were mafia and jaz nor Rothric were, why would sleepy put himself out there like that. This leads me to think sleepy is more town than mafia, but maybe that's how he'd hope ppl would think, I dunno.
This is what I keep coming back to. I don't understand Sleepy's last minute move to save me, then turn around and put me right back in the runoff the following day.
He's never really explained that move.
He said he didn't realize the round would be closing, but it was pretty clearly laid out in the tally and a few posts prior. So whether that's true or not, I don't know.
Looking back to day 1, the only person I'm pretty sure is town at this point is potent. Disregard his rookie "it's day 3, inspector should come out", and other minor hiccups, I do believe he's got the towns best interest in mind. Part of the reason I've cooled suspicions on him is looking back before the day 1 mass exodeus from potent (which at the time I felt could have been a mafia power move), you look at who moved their votes away from him (SFA, Sleepy, Rothric, Phi), two of those ppl got whacked, leaving Sleepy and Rothric. For sleepy to be mafia, he'd have to have a huge set of nuts on him to swing the vote at the last second like that, unless Rothric was mafia as well, and sleepy wanted to save him, which would be foolish as fuck, because this clearly would tie them together. Not a smart move on day one, no less. If sleepy and Rothric were both mafia, they'd let Rothric die and cut their losses. If sleepy were mafia and jaz nor Rothric were, why would sleepy put himself out there like that. This leads me to think sleepy is more town than mafia, but maybe that's how he'd hope ppl would think, I dunno.
Anyway, this leaves Tainted, LD, and EAP. I'm not sure which way to go just yet. And since we have time, I'm not rushing anything just yet.
I stand by asking the inspector to come out. We need the help and we as the townies need to know whether the inspector is still alive.
Looking back to day 1, the only person I'm pretty sure is town at this point is potent. Disregard his rookie "it's day 3, inspector should come out", and other minor hiccups, I do believe he's got the towns best interest in mind. Part of the reason I've cooled suspicions on him is looking back before the day 1 mass exodeus from potent (which at the time I felt could have been a mafia power move), you look at who moved their votes away from him (SFA, Sleepy, Rothric, Phi), two of those ppl got whacked, leaving Sleepy and Rothric. For sleepy to be mafia, he'd have to have a huge set of nuts on him to swing the vote at the last second like that, unless Rothric was mafia as well, and sleepy wanted to save him, which would be foolish as fuck, because this clearly would tie them together. Not a smart move on day one, no less. If sleepy and Rothric were both mafia, they'd let Rothric die and cut their losses. If sleepy were mafia and jaz nor Rothric were, why would sleepy put himself out there like that. This leads me to think sleepy is more town than mafia, but maybe that's how he'd hope ppl would think, I dunno.
Anyway, this leaves Tainted, LD, and EAP. I'm not sure which way to go just yet. And since we have time, I'm not rushing anything just yet.
I stand by asking the inspector to come out. We need the help and we as the townies need to know whether the inspector is still alive.
and so does the mafia. Just saying, you sink or sail your own ship.
I stand by asking the inspector to come out. We need the help and we as the townies need to know whether the inspector is still alive.
and so does the mafia. Just saying, you sink or sail your own ship.
Mafia does not need the info as much on Day 3 in my opinion. We need to know how many mafia we've killed. At best I think it's 1, but quite possible it's 0 and today we have to kill one or we lose. At this point if the inspector is alive s/he has a name plus two guesses - that's a ton of info! It would be very helpful to the townies remaining to try and salvage this.
I stand by asking the inspector to come out. We need the help and we as the townies need to know whether the inspector is still alive.
and so does the mafia. Just saying, you sink or sail your own ship.
This is probably just my inexperience talking, but why wouldn't you want the inspector to come out by Day 3 if you're town?
Definitely get the fact that Mafia will kill them with the next whack. But with one given name, and two guesses, they should have a pretty firm grasp on things by this point.
It also gets risky because the chances of surviving the whack on Night 3 get slimmer simply by the number of townies left. Absolute best case scenario, assuming the town lynched two mafia on the first two days, the inspector and townies outnumber mafia 6 to 1. In that scenario, ya, not that high probability of being randomly picked.
But, if the numbers are 5 to 2 or 4 to 3 town:mafia, there aren't that many other townies to hide behind for the whack.
Being the inspector and getting whacked without being able to share your info with the town kind of sucks.
So I totally get why you might not come out on Day 3, but don't see it as a rookie move necessarily.
and so does the mafia. Just saying, you sink or sail your own ship.
This is probably just my inexperience talking, but why wouldn't you want the inspector to come out by Day 3 if you're town?
Definitely get the fact that Mafia will kill them with the next whack. But with one given name, and two guesses, they should have a pretty firm grasp on things by this point.
It also gets risky because the chances of surviving the whack on Night 3 get slimmer simply by the number of townies left. Absolute best case scenario, assuming the town lynched two mafia on the first two days, the inspector and townies outnumber mafia 6 to 1. In that scenario, ya, not that high probability of being randomly picked.
But, if the numbers are 5 to 2 or 4 to 3 town:mafia, there aren't that many other townies to hide behind for the whack.
Being the inspector and getting whacked without being able to share your info with the town kind of sucks.
So I totally get why you might not come out on Day 3, but don't see it as a rookie move necessarily.
it's not the info we'd get from the inspector, but rather calling for inspector to come out. It's a distraction and can easily be held against you.
It's obvious that we want the inspector to come out with info. It doesn't need to be said out loud. There plenty of reasons that the inspector would choose to attempt to go into round 4 in hopes that they get through the night, and just as many to just come out in day 3 (or day 2 even).
Again, my point is that calling for inspector is a bad move regardless of your roll. I will get twisted on you in the end.
This is probably just my inexperience talking, but why wouldn't you want the inspector to come out by Day 3 if you're town?
Definitely get the fact that Mafia will kill them with the next whack. But with one given name, and two guesses, they should have a pretty firm grasp on things by this point.
It also gets risky because the chances of surviving the whack on Night 3 get slimmer simply by the number of townies left. Absolute best case scenario, assuming the town lynched two mafia on the first two days, the inspector and townies outnumber mafia 6 to 1. In that scenario, ya, not that high probability of being randomly picked.
But, if the numbers are 5 to 2 or 4 to 3 town:mafia, there aren't that many other townies to hide behind for the whack.
Being the inspector and getting whacked without being able to share your info with the town kind of sucks.
So I totally get why you might not come out on Day 3, but don't see it as a rookie move necessarily.
it's not the info we'd get from the inspector, but rather calling for inspector to come out. It's a distraction and can easily be held against you.
It's obvious that we want the inspector to come out with info. It doesn't need to be said out loud. There plenty of reasons that the inspector would choose to attempt to go into round 4 in hopes that they get through the night, and just as many to just come out in day 3 (or day 2 even).
Again, my point is that calling for inspector is a bad move regardless of your roll. I will get twisted on you in the end.
Gotcha, misunderstood your initial point. Makes sense.
This is probably just my inexperience talking, but why wouldn't you want the inspector to come out by Day 3 if you're town?
Definitely get the fact that Mafia will kill them with the next whack. But with one given name, and two guesses, they should have a pretty firm grasp on things by this point.
It also gets risky because the chances of surviving the whack on Night 3 get slimmer simply by the number of townies left. Absolute best case scenario, assuming the town lynched two mafia on the first two days, the inspector and townies outnumber mafia 6 to 1. In that scenario, ya, not that high probability of being randomly picked.
But, if the numbers are 5 to 2 or 4 to 3 town:mafia, there aren't that many other townies to hide behind for the whack.
Being the inspector and getting whacked without being able to share your info with the town kind of sucks.
So I totally get why you might not come out on Day 3, but don't see it as a rookie move necessarily.
it's not the info we'd get from the inspector, but rather calling for inspector to come out. It's a distraction and can easily be held against you.
It's obvious that we want the inspector to come out with info. It doesn't need to be said out loud. There plenty of reasons that the inspector would choose to attempt to go into round 4 in hopes that they get through the night, and just as many to just come out in day 3 (or day 2 even).
Again, my point is that calling for inspector is a bad move regardless of your roll. I will get twisted on you in the end.
I don't necessarily agree but see your point and can agree to disagree.
it's not the info we'd get from the inspector, but rather calling for inspector to come out. It's a distraction and can easily be held against you.
It's obvious that we want the inspector to come out with info. It doesn't need to be said out loud. There plenty of reasons that the inspector would choose to attempt to go into round 4 in hopes that they get through the night, and just as many to just come out in day 3 (or day 2 even).
Again, my point is that calling for inspector is a bad move regardless of your roll. I will get twisted on you in the end.
I don't necessarily agree but see your point and can agree to disagree.
Do you have a vote?
awful bossy today army we? Inspector come out, boner vote now.
We have the weekend. And I'm gonna put the votes and whacks to work until I can decide which way to go. Also wanna see what others have to say about the Phi whack.
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Post by Tainted Opossum on Sept 19, 2015 11:07:15 GMT -5
Im torn on who to vote for. Boner, I have an inclination to vote for you simply because you are shuffling me in to the mix with what are presumably guilty parties when I know for fact that I'm town. I'm not convinced we have or have not managed to sniff out mafia yet, but I'm also not entirely convinced that boner is Mafia. Franky Boner, the only reason I'd assume you're the third mafia is because I am not the only one who has had a difficult time pegging down our feelings on you.
Tainted >> null
I'm here, I'm rereading and I'll put something on the board as soon as i feel good about it. Or twelve hours before close of round.
Im torn on who to vote for. Boner, I have an inclination to vote for you simply because you are shuffling me in to the mix with what are presumably guilty parties when I know for fact that I'm town. I'm not convinced we have or have not managed to sniff out mafia yet, but I'm also not entirely convinced that boner is Mafia. Franky Boner, the only reason I'd assume you're the third mafia is because I am not the only one who has had a difficult time pegging down our feelings on you.
Tainted >> null
I'm here, I'm rereading and I'll put something on the board as soon as i feel good about it. Or twelve hours before close of round.
I get the knee jerk reaction to consider putting a vote on me due to me including you in the 3 I feel could potentially be mafia, and furthermore appreciate you resisting the urge to follow through for now. Given the context of the post I mentioned you in, you can at least see where I'm coming from, right? I know I'm town too, I know SFA and phi were probably town too, and that's it. Everything else is guess work and perception. If it's any consolation, I find EAP much more suspicious than you or LD. But that's all just on gut feeling.
I don't see why you had to vote null. I'm not voting yet either, usually null is used after you've already cast a vote and not sure where to put it next. But whatevs
Im torn on who to vote for. Boner, I have an inclination to vote for you simply because you are shuffling me in to the mix with what are presumably guilty parties when I know for fact that I'm town. I'm not convinced we have or have not managed to sniff out mafia yet, but I'm also not entirely convinced that boner is Mafia. Franky Boner, the only reason I'd assume you're the third mafia is because I am not the only one who has had a difficult time pegging down our feelings on you.
Tainted >> null
I'm here, I'm rereading and I'll put something on the board as soon as i feel good about it. Or twelve hours before close of round.
I get the knee jerk reaction to consider putting a vote on me due to me including you in the 3 I feel could potentially be mafia, and furthermore appreciate you resisting the urge to follow through for now. Given the context of the post I mentioned you in, you can at least see where I'm coming from, right? I know I'm town too, I know SFA and phi were probably town too, and that's it. Everything else is guess work and perception. If it's any consolation, I find EAP much more suspicious than you or LD. But that's all just on gut feeling.
I don't see why you had to vote null. I'm not voting yet either, usually null is used after you've already cast a vote and not sure where to put it next. But whatevs
I did it mostly to avoid the "where's tainteds vote!" comments from the peanut gallery.
I get the knee jerk reaction to consider putting a vote on me due to me including you in the 3 I feel could potentially be mafia, and furthermore appreciate you resisting the urge to follow through for now. Given the context of the post I mentioned you in, you can at least see where I'm coming from, right? I know I'm town too, I know SFA and phi were probably town too, and that's it. Everything else is guess work and perception. If it's any consolation, I find EAP much more suspicious than you or LD. But that's all just on gut feeling.
I don't see why you had to vote null. I'm not voting yet either, usually null is used after you've already cast a vote and not sure where to put it next. But whatevs
I did it mostly to avoid the "where's tainteds vote!" comments from the peanut gallery.
<<<<<<<<< peanut gallery (that's pointing to me, btw)
