Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
I think it's odd that a couple people's reaction is that Maddog was whacked for his tone/style this game instead of anything he said. Gonna go for Dan for now. I feel like Maddog could have been trying to advise Silver/us not to discount the idea of Danbob being Mafia because of how quickly Dan voted.
My guess is that Mafia was thinking Maddog looked different personality wise than he usually does. That's what I mostly took away from reading the above. But I also think there is a case that it points to Kanye or Tranter. Will look into it more later.
I agree w Rummy that he was a bit off so I pressed him a bit once but that’s out of suspicion that he was mafia. So I’m not sure how this makes me sus.
My guess is that Mafia was thinking Maddog looked different personality wise than he usually does. That's what I mostly took away from reading the above. But I also think there is a case that it points to Kanye or Tranter. Will look into it more later.
I agree w Rummy that he was a bit off so I pressed him a bit once but that’s out of suspicion that he was mafia. So I’m not sure how this makes me sus.
My feeling that MD was off and the idea that there is a case to be made for you are two separate concepts. Id actually retract him pointing to you since he was kinda just responding to your pressing him.
Im not buying that you pressed md because you thought he was off by the way. You pressed him very, very early. My call here is that you pressed him before it would have been at all possible to notice him being off. And I also dont know if youve played enough games with Maddog to catch on to him being off that quickly.
I agree w Rummy that he was a bit off so I pressed him a bit once but that’s out of suspicion that he was mafia. So I’m not sure how this makes me sus.
My feeling that MD was off and the idea that there is a case to be made for you are two separate concepts. Id actually retract him pointing to you since he was kinda just responding to your pressing him.
Im not buying that you pressed md because you thought he was off by the way. You pressed him very, very early. My call here is that you pressed him before it would have been at all possible to notice him being off. And I also dont know if youve played enough games with Maddog to catch on to him being off that quickly.
I switched my vote from Kanye to him because I didn’t really like my vote and misread the tally. It doesn’t really have to be a great hunch and that’s why I didn’t go too deep with it. We were also heading into a runoff when I voted for him so I’m not sure how that’s “impossible to notice him being off”. He had made a handful of posts.
My feeling that MD was off and the idea that there is a case to be made for you are two separate concepts. Id actually retract him pointing to you since he was kinda just responding to your pressing him.
Im not buying that you pressed md because you thought he was off by the way. You pressed him very, very early. My call here is that you pressed him before it would have been at all possible to notice him being off. And I also dont know if youve played enough games with Maddog to catch on to him being off that quickly.
I switched my vote from Kanye to him because I didn’t really like my vote and misread the tally. It doesn’t really have to be a great hunch and that’s why I didn’t go too deep with it. We were also heading into a runoff when I voted for him so I’m not sure how that’s “impossible to notice him being off”. He had made a handful of posts.
can you point to the specific posts that made you think he was off at the time you pressed him?
I think it's odd that a couple people's reaction is that Maddog was whacked for his tone/style this game instead of anything he said. Gonna go for Dan for now. I feel like Maddog could have been trying to advise Silver/us not to discount the idea of Danbob being Mafia because of how quickly Dan voted.
Jaz > Danbob
can you expand on why the tone read is odd to you? Is it because you feel like maddog was sounding normal?
I switched my vote from Kanye to him because I didn’t really like my vote and misread the tally. It doesn’t really have to be a great hunch and that’s why I didn’t go too deep with it. We were also heading into a runoff when I voted for him so I’m not sure how that’s “impossible to notice him being off”. He had made a handful of posts.
can you point to the specific posts that made you think he was off at the time you pressed him?
I think it's odd that a couple people's reaction is that Maddog was whacked for his tone/style this game instead of anything he said. Gonna go for Dan for now. I feel like Maddog could have been trying to advise Silver/us not to discount the idea of Danbob being Mafia because of how quickly Dan voted.
Post by potentpotables on Feb 1, 2021 20:15:45 GMT -5
Agreeing with Tranter's post, I found it really odd that Maddog made the comment about voting and then didn't vote for another half-day or so. I commented on it at the time. I guess there's nothing to make of it now except I wonder how it was viewed by mafia. I'm looking back trying to make that connection.
Agreeing with Tranter's post, I found it really odd that Maddog made the comment about voting and then didn't vote for another half-day or so. I commented on it at the time. I guess there's nothing to make of it now except I wonder how it was viewed by mafia. I'm looking back trying to make that connection.
Yes you called it out on page 1. If you and Tranter are mafia together, you guys suck balls at staying distanced. Going to scratch that combination off the list for now.
I think it's odd that a couple people's reaction is that Maddog was whacked for his tone/style this game instead of anything he said. Gonna go for Dan for now. I feel like Maddog could have been trying to advise Silver/us not to discount the idea of Danbob being Mafia because of how quickly Dan voted.
Post by Jake Jortles on Feb 1, 2021 20:30:03 GMT -5
Heres a group we should retroactively study...
Last three to respond substantively to a day 1 whack: silver, bk, kpo
Wonder what the likelihood of having mafia in there is. I do feel like some people as mafia want to observe how others are responding before diving in.
To me the whack clearly points to silver, so he at least deserves to be in the runoff and would like to hear more from him. I'd also like to hear from jaz and KPO who both really have contributed nothing.
Last three to respond substantively to a day 1 whack: silver, bk, kpo
Wonder what the likelihood of having mafia in there is. I do feel like some people as mafia want to observe how others are responding before diving in.
I'm thinking there's a mafia between silver, kpo, and jaz
I’ve been busy this afternoon with shopping, cooking, eating wayyyy too much and taking time to digest. On the phone with my grandma rn. Will read through afterwards
I’ve been busy this afternoon with shopping, cooking, eating wayyyy too much and taking time to digest. On the phone with my grandma rn. Will read through afterwards
what kind of sick man whacks Mad Dog then goes shopping and calls their family like it's nothing
I’ve been busy this afternoon with shopping, cooking, eating wayyyy too much and taking time to digest. On the phone with my grandma rn. Will read through afterwards
what kind of sick man whacks Mad Dog then goes shopping and calls their family like it's nothing
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
I think it's odd that a couple people's reaction is that Maddog was whacked for his tone/style this game instead of anything he said. Gonna go for Dan for now. I feel like Maddog could have been trying to advise Silver/us not to discount the idea of Danbob being Mafia because of how quickly Dan voted.
Jaz > Danbob
I am definitely not counting out the idea that one [or more] of MD's posts points in the direction of one [or more] Maf member and that that's why he was whacked. But I also know that for a Night 1 whack, when there isn't a clear direction of suspicion among the Maf Team on who might be Inspector, using reasoning like "his tone and style seem different than usual, might be because he has a role" is a fairly common one
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
what do you think of maddogs posts all lined up on the last page? Does he look vanilla in them to you?
I think he's probably vanilla but does have a couple posts that could make mafia think otherwise.
1. Someone move off me - mafia night have thought that was a hint idk. Don't think it actually was but one possible reason
2. The one agreeing with Theo about not liking the runoff- Possible scenario that no mafia were in the runoff / could make the mafia members think Maddog had a name of someone not in the runoff
3. The weird one asking me to be the deciding voter- obviously points to me. But could also point to dan in that MD had fans name and didn't want dan to have the deciding vote
4. Last voter on BKB and then switching for a weak reason to theo- Mafia BKB could think Maddog took long to vote because he was inspector and didn't know who to vote for and then ultimately went with his given. Maddog then could've regretted that decision and tried to switch to theo to make it seem like he didn't have bkbs name
So I think it points to Me, Dan, or BKB. I remember feeling off about BKB day 1 but that is still just gut and now a stretch reasoning.
I think it's odd that a couple people's reaction is that Maddog was whacked for his tone/style this game instead of anything he said. Gonna go for Dan for now. I feel like Maddog could have been trying to advise Silver/us not to discount the idea of Danbob being Mafia because of how quickly Dan voted.
Jaz > Danbob
That post I think you're referring to was actually Maddog advising me that Theo could be mafia in spite of his quick voting. Dan voted 5th so it wasn't that fast that game. Think he was just using dan as an example of a mafia member that may vote within 30 seconds.
I think it's odd that a couple people's reaction is that Maddog was whacked for his tone/style this game instead of anything he said. Gonna go for Dan for now. I feel like Maddog could have been trying to advise Silver/us not to discount the idea of Danbob being Mafia because of how quickly Dan voted.
Jaz > Danbob
That post I think you're referring to was actually Maddog advising me that Theo could be mafia in spite of his quick voting. Dan voted 5th so it wasn't that fast that game. Think he was just using dan as an example of a mafia member that may vote within 30 seconds.
I asked Jaz about this (to find the post) specifically because it was wrong. I wish you would have let him answer.
I am sus of Jortles and Rummy because they both usually talk a lot in here and up until today were both fairly quiet (rummy started talking a little earlier than Jortles).
Going KPO > BKB because i don't really know who he is. Open to changing this as more time passes because I want to see more arguing
Gonna throw my dart back at BKB for now. Whack can point to him, had a gut feeling day 1, one of the people to respond to the whack.
Silver > BKB
I actually think maddog’s posts point away from me more than anything. He threw an initial vote on me but then moved off. (That’s not exactly mafia distancing since MD was whacked by mafia).
He called Silver weird for voting for me. I end up surviving round 1 and Silver again is going after me without anything but his “gut,” whatever that’s worth, and some whackjob theory that I posted in a game where people post things?
I am sus of Jortles and Rummy because they both usually talk a lot in here and up until today were both fairly quiet (rummy started talking a little earlier than Jortles).
Going KPO > BKB because i don't really know who he is. Open to changing this as more time passes because I want to see more arguing
- mafia night have thought that was a hint idk. Don't think it actually was but one possible reason
