Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Ok this is why I didn't end the game when the round was over. If I ended the game then then in future games if we're in the same type of situation but a mafia member is in the runoff then town will know they've got a mafia member in the runoff. Then if they don't get them that day they can just get him the next. I also asked the mafia to do the same thing and just let it play out because the same kind of thing could happen in the future. If mafia didn't start celebrating then town knows there's a mafia member in the runoff so they could get them that day or the next.
But there would be no next day to get him if they didn't get it right...
Im so frustrated with myself for allowing vote history to override personality reads I feel like I never do that. Kanye looked so mafia to me. Tranter looke so town to me. and I allowed a stack with rummy on theo to overcome that.
If anyone ever needed a case study on why analyzing votes is absolutely dogshit just review this game or the one where Me theo and teddy had two of us stack on the other. Never again.
Good job guys.
I said multiple times to Silv & Theo during this D4 “oof jostles is gonna be big mad at himself if he goes against his gut”
But hey, there have been times I went with my gut and was wrong, so head and heart can both lead astray in this game
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Ok this is why I didn't end the game when the round was over. If I ended the game then then in future games if we're in the same type of situation but a mafia member is in the runoff then town will know they've got a mafia member in the runoff. Then if they don't get them that day they can just get him the next. I also asked the mafia to do the same thing and just let it play out because the same kind of thing could happen in the future. If mafia didn't start celebrating then town knows there's a mafia member in the runoff so they could get them that day or the next.
i dont think there is anything wrong with knowing there is mafia in the runoff. Why would you make us waste real life time when the game is over
Because then it basically give town a role confirmation which I don't think should happen
Ok this is why I didn't end the game when the round was over. If I ended the game then then in future games if we're in the same type of situation but a mafia member is in the runoff then town will know they've got a mafia member in the runoff. Then if they don't get them that day they can just get him the next. I also asked the mafia to do the same thing and just let it play out because the same kind of thing could happen in the future. If mafia didn't start celebrating then town knows there's a mafia member in the runoff so they could get them that day or the next.
But there would be no next day to get him if they didn't get it right...
In this case yeah, I'm talking in a hypothetical future game where there actually is a mafia member in the runoff.
Post by potentpotables on Mar 2, 2021 23:37:22 GMT -5
Good game to all. Especially well done by mafia all game. You were wise to whack me because I was coming for Theo D3. Did Kanye get a vote this whole game? I didn't pay close attention to tallies but if he did, it certainly didn't feel like it after D1.
i dont think there is anything wrong with knowing there is mafia in the runoff. Why would you make us waste real life time when the game is over
Because then it basically give town a role confirmation which I don't think should happen
its not a role confirmation of a specific person it just lets you know the game is not over and is on the line.
Ive talked about this plenty in the past with I think potent and people dont agree with me. It doesnt really matter because the day a mafia makes me spend any additional hours on a game when its already over is actually going to be the day I quit the game. I know mafia will do the right thing anyways and think it should just be in the rules.
But there would be no next day to get him if they didn't get it right...
In this case yeah, I'm talking in a hypothetical future game where there actually is a mafia member in the runoff.
Right. But if there are two - let's say Kanye and Teddy in this game - and they kill Kanye, they'll know anyway, and if they kill Teddy, game is over. I get your point, and it's one I hadn't thought of necessarily. I just don't think it's a huge deal. Everybody knew 2 of the 5 were mafia. Everybody knew a mafia had to die for the game to continue.
Post by Jake Jortles on Mar 2, 2021 23:39:33 GMT -5
Wish I got more aggressive when I told kanye I caught him. Wasnt confident enough and didnt realize I actually did. So many fucking regrets this game lets start the next.
Because then it basically give town a role confirmation which I don't think should happen
its not a role confirmation of a specific person it just lets you know the game is not over and is on the line.
Ive talked about this plenty in the past with I think potent and people dont agree with me. It doesnt really matter because the day a mafia makes me spend any additional hours on a game when its already over is actually going to be the day I quit the game. I know mafia will do the right thing anyways and think it should just be in the rules.
I am 100 emoji with you on this one. I even PMd JTR to talk about it.
Good game to all. Especially well done by mafia all game. You were wise to whack me because I was coming for Theo D3. Did Kanye get a vote this whole game? I didn't pay close attention to tallies but if he did, it certainly didn't feel like it after D1.
I was pretty sure I was going kanye if I made it nice whack. didn't feel theo at all though.
I definitely thought town might go Theo or Silv d4, but we felt pretty confident that if one of them was role revealed as mafia, the next move would *not* be to go for the remaining one. Even jostles said he basically counted out that combo.
It definitely made me chuckle when I got my mafia PM right after I’d been making jokes about paying off JTR to get a non vanilla role again at long last lololol but I promise, no under-the-table payment actually did occur
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
In this case yeah, I'm talking in a hypothetical future game where there actually is a mafia member in the runoff.
Right. But if there are two - let's say Kanye and Teddy in this game - and they kill Kanye, they'll know anyway, and if they kill Teddy, game is over. I get your point, and it's one I hadn't thought of necessarily. I just don't think it's a huge deal. Everybody knew 2 of the 5 were mafia. Everybody knew a mafia had to die for the game to continue.
I'm a 1000% in the "if mafia isn't in runoff in a point where RO closes and mafia isn't in it" to just close the window in embarrassing fashion
Post by Jake Jortles on Mar 2, 2021 23:44:14 GMT -5
I cant lie... something else that creeped into my head really late was how hard I went in favor of tranter and the pain I would suffer personally if he pulled one on me and never let me forget about it. Ughhhjh i had him read so correctly what have i done
I cant lie... something else that creeped into my head really late was how hard I went in favor of tranter and the pain I would suffer personally if he pulled one on me and never let me forget about it. Ughhhjh i had him read so correctly what have i done
Not gonna lie we did have a lot of fun laughing at your reads in maf thread
I cant lie... something else that creeped into my head really late was how hard I went in favor of tranter and the pain I would suffer personally if he pulled one on me and never let me forget about it. Ughhhjh i had him read so correctly what have i done
I definitely keyed too hard into jaz but 20/20 the other available options weren't any better do hindsight it didn't matter 🤷
Post by Cookin' Mama on Mar 2, 2021 23:47:34 GMT -5
Ok, though rare, I think this will effect future games but I'll end it when there's no mafia in a runoff and the game is unwinnable in the future if that's what you guys want.
Ok, though rare, I think this will effect future games but I'll end it when there's no mafia in a runoff and the game is unwinnable in the future if that's what you guys want.
I cant lie... something else that creeped into my head really late was how hard I went in favor of tranter and the pain I would suffer personally if he pulled one on me and never let me forget about it. Ughhhjh i had him read so correctly what have i done
Not gonna lie we did have a lot of fun laughing at your reads in maf thread
Ok, though rare, I think this will effect future games but I'll end it when there's no mafia in a runoff and the game is unwinnable in the future if that's what you guys want.
I definitely feel like once the math is done the game is done no reason to walk on eggshells through a finished game
Ok, though rare, I think this will effect future games but I'll end it when there's no mafia in a runoff and the game is unwinnable in the future if that's what you guys want.
I definitely feel like once the math is done the game is done no reason to walk on eggshells through a finished game
Yeah, I mean I agree that it would be an annoying thing to have to do
Can we talk about the meta here and how we can stop screwing the inspectors?
lmao inspector needs to just stop being shady
But what is shady? Especially on Day One? I didn't feel I did anything shady in 136 until I revealed when we still had 3 left. What did KPO do that was shady here? I didn't think there was anything.
Can we talk about the meta here and how we can stop screwing the inspectors?
lmao inspector needs to just stop being shady
100% its on the inspectors not on us for recognizing the shadiness. Just want to note again that I recently fucked up inspector and had to reveal day one as well so not pointing fingers. Just feel like we havent learned that part of being inspector as a group
