Mafia 160 - Heartbreak Island

I'm having a hard time with all the people jumping to believe maddog. That seems like a mafia move to me. I'm definitely noting who is struggling with his reveal and who is not.

You know it would be really funny if Jortles is mafia again with maddog and they set up a terrible fake inspector plot to make Jortles get to d5 again lol

would be funny but it seems like a surefire way to get both of them whacked / exiled instead of just one of them

I remember reading a game where you stood basically alone on this and were right. So I’m willing to listen.

What do you think about my logic if a fake at that time? It just seems badly planned but that certainly doesn’t make it impossible I guess.

Jortles is gonna be so happy when he shows up and gets to decide which woman he wants to throw out of the game

lmao

and I'm fine w either of the ladies being suspects just because both of their votes for me were warrantless, but in my head

potentially..

a. they already picked up on otter being given, rummy definitely has my last game on rolodex compared to everyone else

b. cums push to 4 to see what happens was probably bait and I took it

c. idk they're both mafia but that might've been too bold w me having a guess in my pocket

if they picked up on me and otter they probably would've been better off to just whack immediately but then they'd lose the power and everyone would've caught on eventually

Honestly it is SO textbook that that’s part of what worries me here. I know when I’ve been on a Maf team before and discussing w my teammates about doing a potential fake, it has come into convo like “well if I did it, and executed it like xyz they might buy it because that’s how I played it last time I rly was inspo.”

I still lean that MD is truthing & just seems to only have one way he plays the inspector role, but it isn’t absurd to consider the other possibility.

I feel like we’ve been in an all town runoff since the beginning ughhhh

Though I really don’t have enough to get a read on rummy

I hope Jortles is the real inspector to really blow the lid off this thing lol. Haven't heard from him at all

if your town I get it, that's why it's so frustrating, both times it wasn't even mafia who got me in a mess

if your mafia eat my boogers

dude, slow your roll. I will try to say this as delicately as possible, but right now it's less about you and more about everybody reacting to you. I've not said I don't believe you. I've said I have questions. I've asked questions. I'm skeptical of everything, but it doesn't mean I don't believe you or won't eventually believe you. And it's a valid question to ask why you haven't been whacked yet. Which isn't a question I'm asking you.

Did you even notice that I originally voted for Otter? I then moved my vote. I'm asking this because it would have made sense for an inspector with Otters name to note this and guess me.

Day 1 Round 2
INSPO Maddog 4 - (Jortles*, Otter^, Rummy, Cum)
TOWN Jortles 2 - (Tranter, Teddy)
Rummy 2 - (SFA, Potent)
Cum 2 - (Theo, Rooloo)

-if mafia had 2 on me they probably both need to die to hedge
-feel it's more likely teddy than tranter, could be wrong, tranter not having a vote is a key for me though
-no read on sfa, as Potent mentioned there's reason to look into him
-could see either of these being maf, Theo being in the batch w no votes as well

step 1: rummy exile, md whack
step 2: otter exile, jortles whack (probably happens before he can really dig in so would like him to get as much out today as he can)
step 3: jortles voter or potent exile exile, whack
step 4: jortles voter or cum exile, whack

idk I think this is the best hedge, could be way fucking off but whatever this is the situation now, d3 on is crap shoot

sorry but why would I be exiled for voting Jortles? I voted him first thing bc he got me last game and never needed to move