Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
I'll suspect Fishingmaniac as mafia if this thread comes to include a gruesome, three-paragraph whack story.
This statement merely encourages people to write gruesome brutal death stories in order to frame me. Oh wait. I am mafia. ;D
Tara is innocent and I'll prove it. All but one person has voted for Tara. Three people remain. One of which is me. I'm not really mafia folks - just a wise a$$. ;D That being said, I find it very unlikely that 2 of 3 mafia are waiting until the end instead of trying to influence the vote from early on. The mafia do not vote for their own. Even if they wanted to throw the twons people of the trail they wouldn't take the risk in the first day. Do the math people. Math proves all and the math doesn't indicate that Tara is mafia. I wish I could remember how to do those logic proofs from H.S. This would be a good place for one.
plus, to be honest, I am still getting a hang of this game haha
i'm so confused...
I'm innocent for goodness sake!
He's trying to the "I don't know what's going on so I must be innocent"card. And it seems like a little too much defense for somebody who wasn't close to getting voted off. GUILTY
I'm leaning towards Higgi being innocent now, so at the moment I'm down to a list of four suspects for three Mafia.
Just curious as to why you think Higgi is now innoncent? What changed your thinking? I want to make sure I'm not missing anything.
1. We are in a three-way run-off vote. Higgi voted early, which I think counts for something. Higgi was the third vote for Tara and fourth overall. I can understand a Mafia jumping on the bandwagon of an inevitable decision late in the vote, but not that early on when it counts.
2. If the Mafia were after Handgun, they could have advanced her to the run-off. There's three mafia, and any way you slice it Handgun only got two votes. I now think it's less likely the Mafia were after Handgun - I think they were after RonBurgandy? now - and in that light Higgi looks a lot more innocent.
The most significant vote-stacks on the initial vote were against Tara, Higgi & RonBurgandy? I can't deny that I swung some votes towards Higgi myself - but I thought he looked guilty.
What I feel to be the Inspector's comment on that first vote is important because it implicated Tara (btw, can someone please tell me I'm not the only one who sees this?)
If Tara is mafia, there are two other mafia votes to be found in the voting record. I believe the mafia are definitely hiding within the votes for people who got multiple votes.
Higgi has three votes because I thought he was guilty by association and called him out on it. Two people who sounded Inspector-ish countered Tara, which is why I think we're right in going after her. I was primarily suspicious of Higgi because he was so quick to second a presumably-guilty player's vote; but the more I think about things the more I think he's innocent. I know the Mafia wasn't targeting Higgi, because I know I'm a Townsperson. Handgun switched her vote from Tara to Higgi, and since the Inspector seems to be on her side I think that's more evidence Handgun is not mafia.
Kelaroo had two votes, one of which was Sadie. Sadie & Kelaroo voted for each other, which seems like business as usual for a first round. I think this suggests they're both innocent. I'm not sure what's up with Fishingmaniac changing his vote to Kelaroo at the end of voting, though. My best guess is that piling on Kelaroo was not mafia-directed.
Tara got three votes for her. One was the initial one from Handgun, which she reciprocated. The other two votes for Tara came from the people I most suspect to be Inspector. I think it was safer for the Inspector to join the Tara voters after Handgun voted, because they wouldn't be the only one at that point. I can't think the Mafia was voting for Tara if I think the Inspector is voting for Tara.
Which leaves me with my last group of voters - those who voted for RonBurgandy? Krizzeam, Tara, and NothingButFlowers
First, we have the fact that these people are voting alongside Tara, whom I believe the Inspector has indicated is Mafia.
Krizzeam is suspect to me, not just because of that vote, but also because of his shady posts directed towards me at the beginning of Day One.
Tara switched her vote to RonBurgandy? I don't think it was entirely to save her hide, because we have a three-way run-off. RonBurgandy? isn't the only player she could have switched her vote to in order to have a run-off. She could have voted for Higgi, but didn't. I think she saw that I was off-track with that flawed theory, and didn't want to discredit it.
Rooconteur's vote flip-flopped enough that I think he's innocent.
NBF voted for RonBurgandy? late in the voting, which qualified him for the run-off vote. I can't verify it, but I suspect that was an effort to save Tara. I think it's quite possible that Tara set NBF up to be in a position to force RonBurgandy? into the run-off.
Then we have Fishingmaniac. He's been among the last to vote both rounds so far. He laid back and only voted for people who already had votes. That seems to fit the profile of the Mafia behavior I'm calling out here...
Tara is innocent and I'll prove it. All but one person has voted for Tara. Three people remain. One of which is me. I'm not really mafia folks - just a wise a$$. ;D That being said, I find it very unlikely that 2 of 3 mafia are waiting until the end instead of trying to influence the vote from early on. The mafia do not vote for their own.
You cannot tell me the Mafia have never voted for their own. Re-read Game 12, Day Two: Bama & I were mafia, and we went after one of our own.
If the mafia see that one of their own going down is inevitable, I would think the logical thing to do would be to succumb to it rather than resist it. In this case, even minus three votes, there is a majority consensus that Tara is mafia. All three Mafia could switch their votes to either RB? or Higgi, and the result would be the same. They know they couldn't reverse that even if they tried. Their best-case scenario at this point is to force yet another run-off between Tara & Higgi.
Even though they can't reverse it, the Mafia still have to look innocent for appearances' sake, lest their lifespan be shortened. There is ample reason to believe that the Mafia will vote Tara in the run-off, just to camouflage themselves in with the Townspeople.
Then we have Fishingmaniac. He's been among the last to vote both rounds so far. He laid back and only voted for people who already had votes. That seems to fit the profile of the Mafia behavior I'm calling out here...
False. I voted for ronburgandy? second round. I'm the only person who voted for ronburgandy? second round. You yourself tallied the votes several times.
And just for the record, I'm the inspector. That's how come I know that I'm mafia.
Then we have Fishingmaniac. He's been among the last to vote both rounds so far. He laid back and only voted for people who already had votes. That seems to fit the profile of the Mafia behavior I'm calling out here...
False. I voted for ronburgandy? second round. I'm the only person who voted for ronburgandy? second round. You yourself tallied the votes several times.
And just for the record, I'm the inspector. That's how come I know that I'm mafia.
Fishing, Let me just state, that I actually root for you to stay alive because you make me laugh.
Kdogg- Please don't have another runoff. Why would we need one?
The rules state that run-offs come in the event of a tie vote. I'm not even the Referee, so I wouldn't be conducting any further run-offs. I'm against another run-off, myself.
What I was saying was that, once Tara had 6-7 votes, the Mafia wouldn't have been able to prevent Tara's death. I said it was their best-case scenario, because at the time they could have caused a 6-6-1 tie. That would have led to another run-off, which would have kept Tara alive longer.
Then we have Fishingmaniac. He's been among the last to vote both rounds so far. He laid back and only voted for people who already had votes. That seems to fit the profile of the Mafia behavior I'm calling out here...
False. I voted for ronburgandy? second round. I'm the only person who voted for ronburgandy? second round. You yourself tallied the votes several times.
You did vote for RonBurgandy? in the second round - you were the second-to-last voter. So that fits the "laid back" part of things.
RonBurgandy? already had votes - it's how he got to this run-off.
But in the first round of voting, you shuffled around between people who already had votes. I'm calling out Mafia shenanigans I saw in the first round of voting, and as I already stated, your behavior fits the profile of those Mafia shenanigans.
Ten of us seem to think Tara is guilty, and you don't go along with that. I think there's more grounds to suspect Higgi than RonBurgandy?, and you didn't vote for Higgi either... You voted for RonBurgandy?, who to me appears to be the most-likely-innocent player in this run-off. I think you're up to some shenanigans yourself.
Post by ☮ superbek ☮ on Mar 17, 2009 13:53:19 GMT -5
RETRO DEATH STORY (written by strum, Mafia 7)
tarae22 was wandering around Bonnaroo trying to find the Allman Brother's show but just couldn't find them so she got on the ferris wheel to see if she could seem them from the top. She asked a person on the ferris wheel if he knew where they were playing just as they were reaching the top of the ferris wheel and the person replied "Didn't ya hear? The ABB had to cancel, but don't worry they replaced them with Celine Dion!"
tarae22 couldn't fathom this and had to take a step back, but apparently forgot she was in a ferris wheel. Luckily, no body else was injured as she plummeted to her death.
*EDIT: Night 1 has begun (obviously).
PMs from: Mafia (with death story) Nurse Inspector
I might not be around much longer to say this, and I'd rather regret saying it than not saying it. This might be my Final Thought for the game.
Dear Inspector, Nurse & Vigilante:
Along with my list of suspected Mafia, I've got a list of those I presume to be innocent.
That list, in alphabetical order, consists of: Bamadancer Handgunhips Jack324 kdogg (I know I'm innocent) Kelaroo RonBurgandy? Rooconteur Sadielady
If I'm right, at least two if not all of your names are on this list. If I get whacked, could you do me a favor and look out for all of them?
Nurse, I request that you don't protect me tonight. There are other names on than list who need it more than I. Also, I have no idea who you are so good job with the stealth.
Inspector, I think you should inquire about Krizzeam or Fishingmaniac next. I'm pretty sure at least one of them is mobbed up.