Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Post by GratefulHippie on Aug 5, 2010 18:12:45 GMT -5
btw, if this is how the game is going to continue, i'm just going to quit. obviously the ref doesn't like me, as evidenced by the PM i received back, and she is also obviously speaking to other players outside of this thread. and, well, isn't there a rule about that? just curious...
Im sorry but to me this makes ZERO sense. I have always payed more attention to Kdogg than any other mafia player, since my first or second game when someone mentioned that he was better than everybody else. I figured if he is the best I should try to learn as much as I can from him.
One thing I could never, ever see him doing is approving the mafia to kill one of its own on night 1. Especially in a game like this where there is a ton of confusion. I just don't buy it at all.
I think more likely Kdogg's death proves that all three Wolf, Kdogg and Higgi are innocent. I believe that the mafia killed Kdogg in order to make Wolf and/ or Higgi look guilty.
Mafia would want you to think this way. Why would you pay more attention to Kdogg than any of the other players? In a game like this you can't just pay attention to one player because you "think" they're better. There are a lot of players in this game who are as good or better than Kdogg at mafia. So, in order for your vote to be really be worth something you should pay attention to every player.
Edit:
Kdogg has so many mafia related pics. That is the cutest!!
Ok I have a really big post coming but first I would like to address this cheating thing.
Kdogg didn't break any rules as far as my interpretation of the rule. The rule reads:
8) Players who have been eliminated are still welcome to post in this thread, but are asked to not say anything leading to any knowledge, suspicions or opinions you might have.
Kdogg did not reveal his role nor give us any suspicions or opinions about the game.
Post by GratefulHippie on Aug 5, 2010 18:23:44 GMT -5
8) Players who have been eliminated (i do believe kdogg was just eliminated) are still welcome to post in this thread, but are asked to not say anything (i do believe he also said something) leading to any knowledge, suspicions or opinions (reiterating that you are a townsperson is KNOWLEDGE you have about the game) you might have.
Also Hippie pretty please don't quit over such a silly little thing. We all know Kdogg likes to push the line and sometimes he gets a bit butt-hurt when he is killed early. Also whether or not EAP likes you I don't think she has done anything to disadvantage you in anyway. Plus she is allowed to PM whoever she wants as ong as she doesn't give any information or help to anyone.
on the one hand i agree with what bacon said (it is not like you don't say you don't like me other people,).
on the other hand, i think kevin should take down ALL the words, as i agree with you on that. just b/c a line is through it doesn't mean you can't see it.
i asked NBF if she could step in as REF, but i am not 100% sure she has finished with the bar.
Last Edit: Aug 5, 2010 18:27:59 GMT -5 by EAP - Back to Top
Also Hippie pretty please don't quit over such a silly little thing. We all know Kdogg likes to push the line and sometimes he gets a bit butt-hurt when he is killed early. Also whether or not EAP likes you I don't think she has done anything to disadvantage you in anyway. Plus she is allowed to PM whoever she wants as ong as she doesn't give any information or help to anyone.
it's not silly when you know the ref is chatting it up with others and lying about things you're saying or not saying. i haven't said a word to anyone that should result in what is coming out of this. also, this is the freaking internet. i'm here because it's entertainment. it ceases to be entertainment when folks start lashing out because of a silly game.
Ok here is my attempt at a long-ass post. Unfortunately I do not believe it is near as informative as those of Kdogg or Indi's from last game. It is also kind of confusing so please ask questions and I will try to answer them.
First of all the most important thing to make record of in my opinion is the voting records of Kdogg and the justification of the votes.
Third Run-off:Kdogg kept his previous vote for Wolf
First of all I believe we can discount the vote for Bek because they are well recorded voting partners.
Every other vote was for Wolf or Higgi. In my mind this gives two possible trains of though. 1. Wolf or Higgi are guilty and the Mafia believed that Kdogg was inspector. 2. Wolf and/or Higgi was innocent and the mafia used killing Kdogg to make us think Wolf was guilty and throw us of the trail of who is really guilty.
Many of you are presenting a third possibility that Kdogg was mafia and had himself killed to throw everyone off of the rest of the mafia's trail. I do not believe there is any way that Kdogg would allow himself or another one of the mafia to be killed in the first round. There was no concrete theory agreed on by the majority of players as to Kdogg being mafia. It would make absolutely NO sense to do this. As Kdogg well knows it would be much better to have 3 mafia alive one of whom is slightly suspected. Than 2 mafia alive. This is because more than anything mafia is a numbers game and Kdogg knows that.
I do not know if Higgi or Wolf are innocent or guilty but I do know however many Mafia are left are laughing at us right now for thinking Kdogg would kill himself.
Here is where my post falls short of a Kdogg post, because here is where he would have a well though out alternate theory as to who may be mafia. Instead I will say that I have no idea who is mafia. I do however believe that Wolf was innocent and Higgi is innocent. I believe that Kdogg was killed to make either or both Wolf and Higgi look guilty and I would love to hear some suggestions on who else may be guilt.
Post by GratefulHippie on Aug 5, 2010 18:28:38 GMT -5
on the one hand i agree with what bacon said (it is not like you don't say you don't like me other people).
if you can prove it, please do. the difference with us is that i don't take this stuff seriously. no, i don't talk badly about you...because i don't even know you, you have no bearing on the rest of my life, and because i just DON'T CARE
1. A townsperson is a ROLE. 2. Kdogg was voted dead therefore ending his tenure in this game. 3. He implied AFTER he was killed that he was a TOWNSPERSON and the voters made a wrong decision. 4. He broke the rules. 5. Lets move on.
on the one hand i agree with what bacon said (it is not like you don't say you don't like me other people,).
on the other hand, i think kevin should take down ALL the words, as i agree with you on that. just b/c a line is through it doesn't mean you can't see it.
i asked NBF if she could step in as REF, but i am not 100% sure she has finished with the bar.
Mafia would want you to think this way. Why would you pay more attention to Kdogg than any of the other players? In a game like this you can't just pay attention to one player because you "think" they're better. There are a lot of players in this game who are as good or better than Kdogg at mafia. So, in order for your vote to be really be worth something you should pay attention to every player.
I don't pay attention to Kdogg more than anyone else in any one game. It's just he is the one that I try to remember strategies from game to game more than any other.
Im sorry but to me this makes ZERO sense. I have always payed more attention to Kdogg than any other mafia player, since my first or second game when someone mentioned that he was better than everybody else. I figured if he is the best I should try to learn as much as I can from him.
Im sorry but to me this makes ZERO sense. I have always payed more attention to Kdogg than any other mafia player, since my first or second game when someone mentioned that he was better than everybody else. I figured if he is the best I should try to learn as much as I can from him.
1. A townsperson is a ROLE. 2. Kdogg was voted dead therefore ending his tenure in this game. 3. He implied AFTER he was killed that he was a TOWNSPERSON and the voters made a wrong decision. 4. He broke the rules. 5. Lets move on.
Yes PLEASE! Kdogg is dead. And we still have at least 2 more to find, so please let's get back to the game.\
Bacon- you said in your post in your words you pay more attention. That's fine if you want his playing methods, but it does seem fishy.
What is wrong with this if there is one player who has good strategy and I try to remember it from game to game more than any other. There is no way I could remember every strategy from every game by every player.
I am in no way saying that I pay more attention to him in the first round of any game. Its not like I follow him blindly. I just don't think he would kill himself in the first round.
Im sorry but to me this makes ZERO sense. I have always payed more attention to Kdogg than any other mafia player, since my first or second game when someone mentioned that he was better than everybody else. I figured if he is the best I should try to learn as much as I can from him.
I also agree with the suspicion of Indi. Not only has his style varied greatly from the last game but also he last second vote change to put Kdogg in the run-off and give Mike D the deciding vote (until Bek changed) was an odd decision.
