Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
And on top of my last post, I keep seeing folks talking about how the first mafia kill is the best way to track down the mafia right? Well I am looking at what led to that vote * someone not wanting me to have the final vote in the first place* along with a last minute change of vote to kill wolf. I am not intending to be pissy or condesending, but I really can't word my posts any better.
it was the closest thing i'd seen to an inspector coming out, which is why i felt comfortable sticking to my vote for bek. once i figured bek was guilty, i also assumed i was correct about my theory that kdogg had offed himself to throw us all off.
bacon...good try with saying you asked about me and kel. you say first night you asked about me...why? the only vote i ever got was the one wolf gave me and he meant it to be higgi. and you say second night you asked about kel...again, why??? not a single thing about her was suspicious, and not a single person even had a comment about her innocence or guilt. i know you say you "sucked", but i refuse to believe after as many games as you've played that you would be THAT bad at asking about the people who were actually being targeted.
townspeople, i urge you to vote bacon so we can end this monster of a game!!
^definitely Hippie. I have always maintained that if you are mafia and Kdogg is not, killing him is always a good idea. He is way too good at this game to keep around. I am going back through every thing to see all the possibilities of what this could indicate if anything at all.
My initial reaction would be that Wolf really was innocent and the mafia is trying to protect someone by making Wolf look guilty. Who knows though.
left to vote: bacon hippie indi jenkazooty mike d (i could 't really tell if you voted in your post or not, sorry) ntrt
I haven't voted yet. need some time to think more. If we vote off bacon, we need figure out who else is mafia first, or at least have a good idea, don't we? I am a little confused about some things, but for the record/future reference as inspector is it alright to ask about someone who is already been voted off?
Post by GratefulHippie on Aug 11, 2010 0:37:02 GMT -5
MikeD...bek is the third mafia. Trust me on this. You know I'm innocent so I'm not trying to lead you astray. Just vote bacon and the game will be over.
Im sorry but to me this makes ZERO sense. I have always payed more attention to Kdogg than any other mafia player, since my first or second game when someone mentioned that he was better than everybody else. I figured if he is the best I should try to learn as much as I can from him.
One thing I could never, ever see him doing is approving the mafia to kill one of its own on night 1. Especially in a game like this where there is a ton of confusion. I just don't buy it at all.
I think more likely Kdogg's death proves that all three Wolf, Kdogg and Higgi are innocent. I believe that the mafia killed Kdogg in order to make Wolf and/ or Higgi look guilty.
I still don't understand why there is nearly unanimous (other than by me) agreement that Kdogg was mafia. The real mafia must be falling off their chair laughing right now.
Right now I don't really know. I honestly don't think Hippie is mafia because in my mind what she is suggesting would make her suspect #1 in 95% of games. My suspicion for Indi still lingers after that last second vote change and the fact he had been fairly mute until we mentioned that it was suspicious.
I really want to hear some more theories though because I'm pretty open to suggestions. I asked for other ideas earlier and basically all I got was NTRT voting for Jen and everybody saying I look suspicious.
I agree with Kel that is a very odd post. Basically Indi says the same things over and over again with lots of spaces between them. That post sounds very forced and like my freashman comp prof and Bilbo Baggins would say "like too little butter on to big a piece of beard".
That post certainly makes me more suspicious of Indi. I think there is a very good chance he made that post just to settle the various suspicions about his relative silence before that point.
I am a little confused about some things, but for the record/future reference as inspector is it alright to ask about someone who is already been voted off?
the inspector may ask about any player, already shark dinner or still swimming.
(hey didn't you enjoy that shark talk? i am sad shark week is over.)
Last Edit: Aug 11, 2010 1:03:54 GMT -5 by EAP - Back to Top
rude.
Mike D
Bonnafunky Dirtyroo King of the Smileys :-)
MikeD...bek is the third mafia. Trust me on this. You know I'm innocent so I'm not trying to lead you astray. Just vote bacon and the game will be over.
You think bek was the other one? I wouldn't doubt it but I don't get why bacon wouldn't have done more to try to save bek unless it's cause of bek's jumping out to save kdogg ??? It does make sense that bacon couldn't do the same thing. Im thinking there are two left. For now. . .
SO as you now know (lol) I am the inspector. I was given Wolf's name in the beginning of the game. I decided I would not try to make a move against wolf to prevent suspicion so I decided to vote Kdogg because I figured he would be the most threatening to me as a mafia if he were one. Once it became obvious to me there was a chance to take out wolf without looking too suspicious I changed my vote to him. I figured since he was getting the heat I wouldn't look suspicious for changing my vote.
Then the whole deal with Indi happened and I almost blew my cover begging someone to change from Kdogg to Wolf. I really wanted to kill Indi for being so stupid and I really wanted hug Bek for saving the day.
My initial suspicion was that Indi and Mike were the other two mafia, but the more I thought about it I decided that it was just to simple. In stead of asking about them I decided to ask about Hippie. As she so meanly states above that was a stupid choice. I had a reason for it when I did it and I can't even really remember what it was. I had a theory though that she was lying low and then figured changing her vote would make her look suspicious. It was stupid I don't know what I was thinking.
After night 1 happy and slightly surprised to be alive I decided it was time for damage control. I starting preaching Wolf's innocence in order to throw the mafia off my trail. I also starting preaching Kdogg's innocence because I was hoping that a towny would get the ball rolling on another suspicious person. I stuck with Bek to keep on the DL.
Once again during night 2 I was considering asking about Mike D, Indi, and one other. This round it was Kel. I didn't ask about Mike D because he had done almost nothing round 2. I didn't ask about Indi because I figured he is dead soon no matter what. I did ask about Kel because of a few things. Mostly her first round voting of Higgi until she had to change to Kdogg in the run-off. Ya I know I should have just realized this was her voting for her partner until she had to pick someone new and then voting for who she thought was most suspicious.
As I have explained before I am very, very confident with Kdoggs innocence. I assume you can see why in my situation I would think this way.
I am also fairly confident about NTRT being innocent due to the fact he is the one who got the ball rolling on ousting Wolf from the first round.
I am pretty sure Bek is innocent because she was the deciding vote that sent Wolf home.
I am also comfortable saying Higgi is innocent since he was killed by the mafia at a point in the game where there was much confusion.
I can also say that I am fairly comfortable about calling Jen Innocent with her voting record in the first round although I became slightly suspicious when she voted me in Round 2.
That leaves us with
Indigrainbow Mike D
These 2 are mafia I am 100% confident of it. I am kicking myself for not going with my instinct from the very beginning and over-thinking everything.
I truly do apologize for sucking so much. I hope you guys can make up for my mistakes.
Post by GratefulHippie on Aug 11, 2010 7:14:54 GMT -5
Sorry, but nothing about that sounds believable. You conveniently can't remember why you asked about me and not a player the townspeople actually thought was guilty? And why on earth, theory in your head or not, would you ask about me when I kept my vote for wolf the entire first round? Wouldn't you at least rule me out that first night based on the fact that I helped oust a "known" mafia member in the very first round of voting?
And I'm sorry but you still had absolutely no reason to ask about kel. Your voting for higgi defense holds no water. Especially when we were completely entrenched in discussion about kdogg, bek, and indi.
Ok so obviously none of you believe me. I have a final request and then I will go off silently. At the end of today Indi and I will die. If like you say AWATD, Bek, and I are mafia the game will be over. When the game continues please vote out Mike D, because then the game will be over and the townies will have won.
During day three there will be three townies and Mike D still alive. So that will be the last chance to win.
hippie jenkazooty mike d ntrt Kel
Baconus66>>>Mike D
I have nothing more to say than sorry I suck at being inspector and quack you all Im seeing My Morning Jacket tomorrow ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
Bacon- if I remember correctly it was you, bek and kgod of mafia. Is what all the townies thought! If this doesn't end, which I'm sure it will, then I would say go after Jen!
Ok so obviously none of you believe me. I have a final request and then I will go off silently. At the end of today Indi and I will die. If like you say AWATD, Bek, and I are mafia the game will be over. When the game continues please vote out Mike D, because then the game will be over and the townies will have won.
During day three there will be three townies and Mike D still alive. So that will be the last chance to win.
hippie jenkazooty mike d ntrt Kel
Baconus66>>>Mike D
I have nothing more to say than sorry I suck at being inspector and quack you all Im seeing My Morning Jacket tomorrow ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
Bacon, your lying through your teeth and you know it. I love how there was someone waiting to do this as soon as I came out as inspector. Townies - I guess we will wait and see what happens when Bacon dies, but if there is someone left, who should I ask about (given they don't kill me off)
Hippie is a townie for sure If the game doesn't end, there is no point in checking on Bek I am guessing that indi is out and was a townie, but honestly I am waiting for him to still jump back in here any second. NTRT, Jen, Kel are left I am leaning towards Jen primarily because she was with Bec and Kdogg with the whole Mike D can't vote last thing in the first round. Kel and NTRT haven't done too much on my radar so far. What do yall think?
I have not read all of page 17 but I have been gunning for Bacon for a while now and I believe MikeD. I had a theory that if Kdogg was guilty either Bacon or Hippie was Mafia. since hippie was the most obvious choice I went with Bacon.
I don't have time to finish reading page 17 because we are short handed at work but if killing Bacon doesn't end this game then I'll go back and reasses the situation.
I have nothing more to say than sorry I suck at being inspector and quack you all Im seeing My Morning Jacket tomorrow ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
I was considering changing my vote from you to MikeD until I read this.
But now you can just go EFF yourself because I am jealous of anyone who gets to spend an evening with MY man Jim.
SERIOUSLY though....if by some insane chance you were inspector you would be the WORST inspector in history "asking" about the people you "asked about".
I am leaning towards Jen primarily because she was with Bec and Kdogg with the whole Mike D can't vote last thing in the first round. Kel and NTRT haven't done too much on my radar so far. What do yall think?
I thought it was Bacon who brought up the whole MikeD voting last thing? Not that it matters now but I don't remember Bek and Kdogg pushing for that.
But you can 100% ask about me because you will find out I am innocent.....and you most likely won't get the chance since I think voting Bacon will end the game....unless someone other than Bek is Mafia.
kel>>>bacon hippie>>>bacon mike D>>>bacon ntrt>>>>bacon bacon>>>mike D jen>>>bacon
left to vote: indi
so the only person we are waiting on is indi. i personally don't think he will be back on inforoo before tomorrow at noon (that's the 36hrs and him missing the vote twice). if nobody objects, i will go ahead and close voting.
i'm going to dinner but i will check back later around 11pm and see what people think.
need some time to think more. If we vote off bacon, we need figure out who else is mafia first, or at least have a good idea, don't we? I am a little confused about some things, but for the record/future reference as inspector is it alright to ask about someone who is already been voted off?
