Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Same here. Our only real option here is to lynch both NBF and Kanye so we are guaranteed to only have 1 mafia left.
... and the town starts seeing the light. Good to have you aboard. Lets wipe these two and get to day 4. Im not passionate about the order still, but NBF’s greater than 0% chance of being inspector makes me think kanye should go now just to at least see NBFs guess whether its fake or real.
Yeah that's not enough of a claim to outweigh the fact that MAFIA WOULDN'T FUCKING WHACK THEIR OWN FAKE INSPECTOR TO LEAVE THE FUCKING REAL ONE ALIVE
Resorting to all caps doesn’t make your point true.
Why wouldn’t mafia whack their own fake inspector if they thought it would make it look like he was telling the truth and I was lying?
There are presumably two mafia members left right now. One of them is Silver Surfer, which I’ve already said.
If they thought I wasn’t likely to identify the third (which I apparently wasn’t since I didn’t), why not leave me alive to make me look guilty and cast doubt on my claim about Silver Surfer and leave a question mark about whether Jaz was the inspector or mafia? If they’d left Jaz alive, wouldn’t he kind of have been in a worse position than I am now? Why not sacrifice him and put me in the position of having to explain myself?
Would he be, tho? If both you and Jaz had been kept alive last night & Mafia decided to just whack a random townie instead, they could've just been counting on the proliferation of confusion caused by it being D2 and there two potential Inspectors alive (with the other one clearly a mafioso instead) with town split on which way to go/who to believe.
You've made some solid points. I'm not sure this is one of them tho, tbh
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Post by Jake Jortles on Apr 19, 2020 15:26:04 GMT -5
But they both need to die subsequently now and d3. Would be a failing to leave any question marks in the air going into day4. We get 2 cracks at it after that.
But they both need to die subsequently now and d3. Would be a failing to leave any question marks in the air going into day4. We get 2 cracks at it after that.
Post by Silver Surfer on Apr 19, 2020 15:27:52 GMT -5
One thing I would like to say. If you guys genuinely think NBF is telling the truth and that Im mafia here are the scenarios.
If you are planning to lynch me first and then lynch NBF tomorrow why would I, as mafia, not choose to just whack NBF? Like genuinely, if we're already two down at that point why would I try again to keep the real inspector alive? It doesn't make any sense
You are saying I would kill my own teammate knowing I had a chance of being lynched D2, and then also keep the real inspector alive if I did get lynched.
I guess at the very least if NBF is whacked then her role is more than likely confirmed. But then again NBF mafia could have planned that from the get go and already has decided to whack herself thus buying even more time for her teammates.
I genuinely think we should lynch the inspector that's still somehow alive before me. But either way I guess we're looking at a day 5 and that means we still have a chance as town
Post by Jim Watson on Apr 19, 2020 15:43:21 GMT -5
Hypothetical: what do we do tomorrow if NBF comes in here saying she guessed _____ and they are mafia? I think that would be a way that a potentially mafia NBF could try and punk us tomorrow.
If we're going to do it this way I think we need to make sure we carry out the whole plan and not let ourselves get played tomorrow and end up not lynching NBF
Hypothetical: what do we do tomorrow if NBF comes in here saying she guessed _____ and they are mafia? I think that would be a way that a potentially mafia NBF could try and punk us tomorrow.
If we're going to do it this way I think we need to make sure we carry out the whole plan and not let ourselves get played tomorrow and end up not lynching NBF
I will be locked on NBF day 3 and evaluating the info she brings during the night.
Hypothetical: what do we do tomorrow if NBF comes in here saying she guessed _____ and they are mafia? I think that would be a way that a potentially mafia NBF could try and punk us tomorrow.
If we're going to do it this way I think we need to make sure we carry out the whole plan and not let ourselves get played tomorrow and end up not lynching NBF
I will be locked on NBF day 3 and evaluating the info she brings during the night.
If we wanna kill her rn I have no complaints either.
Same here. Our only real option here is to lynch both NBF and Kanye so we are guaranteed to only have 1 mafia left.
I think this is the general sentiment among town right now.
The majority of us though do all at least seem in agreement that both NBF & Silver need to go today and tomorrow. My vote is on Silver and I don't see reason to change it, but I do plan to then vote for NBF tomorrow.
If town then has two mafia down, we are in a pretty solid position moving forward.
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Hypothetical: what do we do tomorrow if NBF comes in here saying she guessed _____ and they are mafia? I think that would be a way that a potentially mafia NBF could try and punk us tomorrow.
If we're going to do it this way I think we need to make sure we carry out the whole plan and not let ourselves get played tomorrow and end up not lynching NBF
Yeah I intend to be locked before NBF has a chance to reveal the guess.
I still come back to a fantasy train of thought where the 3 mafia is actually LD / NBF / Kanye. Would be fucking legendary and hilarious.
Hypothetical: what do we do tomorrow if NBF comes in here saying she guessed _____ and they are mafia? I think that would be a way that a potentially mafia NBF could try and punk us tomorrow.
If we're going to do it this way I think we need to make sure we carry out the whole plan and not let ourselves get played tomorrow and end up not lynching NBF
Yeah I intend to be locked before NBF has a chance to reveal the guess.
I still come back to a fantasy train of thought where the 3 mafia is actually LD / NBF / Kanye. Would be fucking legendary and hilarious.
I'd print out this whole game and hang it on my wall
Resorting to all caps doesn’t make your point true.
Why wouldn’t mafia whack their own fake inspector if they thought it would make it look like he was telling the truth and I was lying?
There are presumably two mafia members left right now. One of them is Silver Surfer, which I’ve already said.
If they thought I wasn’t likely to identify the third (which I apparently wasn’t since I didn’t), why not leave me alive to make me look guilty and cast doubt on my claim about Silver Surfer and leave a question mark about whether Jaz was the inspector or mafia? If they’d left Jaz alive, wouldn’t he kind of have been in a worse position than I am now? Why not sacrifice him and put me in the position of having to explain myself?
Would he be, tho? If both you and Jaz had been kept alive last night & Mafia decided to just whack a random townie instead, they could've just been counting on the proliferation of confusion caused by it being D2 and there two potential Inspectors alive (with the other one clearly a mafioso instead) with town split on which way to go/who to believe.
You've made some solid points. I'm not sure this is one of them tho, tbh
Yeah, I was thinking of it as them having either killed me or Jaz, not of the possibility of them just leaving us both alive, which really may have been their best bet, but they obviously didn’t go that way.
again, if NBF is faking, LD is not doctor, than if NBF comes in and says "blank is town/mafia" and that person is the doctor, then we caught them. simple as that.
if nbd is telling the truth, then doctor still has a shot to save her (only one shot so i really don't think it matters if they reveal. they either give her another round by revealing or by saving, but they can't save her twice so it doesn't matter, and they can't save Jaz either, so the power's pretty much over imo)
One thing I would like to say. If you guys genuinely think NBF is telling the truth and that Im mafia here are the scenarios.
If you are planning to lynch me first and then lynch NBF tomorrow why would I, as mafia, not choose to just whack NBF? Like genuinely, if we're already two down at that point why would I try again to keep the real inspector alive? It doesn't make any sense
You are saying I would kill my own teammate knowing I had a chance of being lynched D2, and then also keep the real inspector alive if I did get lynched.
I guess at the very least if NBF is whacked then her role is more than likely confirmed. But then again NBF mafia could have planned that from the get go and already has decided to whack herself thus buying even more time for her teammates.
I genuinely think we should lynch the inspector that's still somehow alive before me. But either way I guess we're looking at a day 5 and that means we still have a chance as town
The problem is none of us know who's telling the truth. The somewhat logical scenarios in my head:
LD and NBF are mafia. LD tried to save his ass with the doctor claim, NBF tried to cover his ass with the inspector claim.
Kanye and Jaz are mafia. Jaz claimed inspector to save himself, and self-lynched to make it seem like he was real.
LD and Kanye are mafia? Kanye tries to distance himself from LD by locking a vote on after Jaz claims inspector, but NBF also claims inspector on Kanye. Maybe Jaz was just trying to stay alive past D1, who knows.
LD and Jaz are mafia? They managed to both get in the D1 runoff, which would be a huge fuckup, and they think that the last mafia can stay well hidden enough to last the rest of the game.
NBF-Kanye, NBF-Jaz make much less sense, and those combos most likely aren't mafia together. There's also a real chance that there's only 1 mafia in this, and I doubt there is all 3 mafia in this.
One thing I would like to say. If you guys genuinely think NBF is telling the truth and that Im mafia here are the scenarios.
If you are planning to lynch me first and then lynch NBF tomorrow why would I, as mafia, not choose to just whack NBF? Like genuinely, if we're already two down at that point why would I try again to keep the real inspector alive? It doesn't make any sense
You are saying I would kill my own teammate knowing I had a chance of being lynched D2, and then also keep the real inspector alive if I did get lynched.
I guess at the very least if NBF is whacked then her role is more than likely confirmed. But then again NBF mafia could have planned that from the get go and already has decided to whack herself thus buying even more time for her teammates.
I genuinely think we should lynch the inspector that's still somehow alive before me. But either way I guess we're looking at a day 5 and that means we still have a chance as town
again, who cares, in this scenario we've killed her and LD, doesn't change the fact that you could still be mafia, or jortles, or anyone, but if shes faking and they self whack. cool. if she tried to distance on you and jortles, thatll play out.
i've already started drinking
