Whether it's your first Bonnaroo or you’re a music festival veteran, we welcome you to Inforoo.
Here you'll find info about artists, rumors, camping tips, and the infamous Roo Clues. Have a look around then create an account and join in the fun. See you at Bonnaroo!!
Last four voters this game, btw - me/SFA/Kanye/Teddy. With all this suspicion on me and SFA this game, I'm surprised this hasn't been mentioned. If it has, I don't recall it.
Ah the classic "throw attention to myself because why would I highlight my own guilt as mafia" tactic
Last four voters this game, btw - me/SFA/Kanye/Teddy. With all this suspicion on me and SFA this game, I'm surprised this hasn't been mentioned. If it has, I don't recall it.
Your vacation is probably the reason it didn't come up lol. Could also be the strange quiet day 1
Holy shit I just read that entire Kanye string of posts and he said almost nothing.
Currently trying to sift through all his quoted thoughts. I am admittedly multi-tasking with Hiss Golden Messenger virtual concert playing rn too, but...
Why do you think it isn't fair to figure that Kanye prob made a typo between Teddy/Theo? Very similar usernames that i've confused more than once myself. I don't think it is wise to try and telegraph too much from it, personally
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Am not gonna try to quote up a storm from Kanye's long post, but I do agree with his assessment that if T were mafia, Jortles would've been a solid whack choice overnight.
Though, idk, in trying to imagine this game if I were mafia, how confident would we have to be with a hunch on someone as Inspector D1 to forego attempting a whack on the Doc (to make him lose his powers) to whack them instead? I think it entirely depends on who our grouping is of Mafia this game and what their play style is like. When DannyB and I were >90% confident that MD was Inspector, we kept him alive anyway for a combo of lols and actual strategy...so, eh, anything is possible
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
D1R1 1. Carini > Theo 2. Dan > Teddy 3. King T > Danbob 4. Theo > Carini 5. Jortles > Teddy 6. Maddog > Jortles 7. Rummy > King T 8. Teddy > King T 9. SFA > Potent 10. Silver > Carini 11. Carini > Theo > Dan 12. Carini > Theo > Dan > Rummy 13. Potent > SFA 14. Carini > Theo > Dan > Rummy > King T 15. Carini > Theo > Dan > Rummy > King T > Teddy 16. Potent > SFA > Theo 17. Danbob > Teddy > Jortles 18. King T > Dan > Carini 19. Jortles > Theo > Tranter 20. Jortles > Theo > Tranter > Theo 21. Maddog > Jortles > Theo 22. Theo > Carini > Jortles 23. Potent > SFA > Theo > SFA
D1R2 24. Carini > Theo 25. SFA > Carini 26. Potent > King T
D1R3 27. Danbob > Theo 28. Theo > King T 29. King T > Carini > Theo 30. Theo > King T > Carini 31. Carini > Theo > King T 32. Jortles > Theo > Carini 33. Maddog > Theo > King T 34. King T > Theo > Carini
Night One, Round One will end Thursday, July 2, at 8PM ET.
Holy shit I just read that entire Kanye string of posts and he said almost nothing.
Currently trying to sift through all his quoted thoughts. I am admittedly multi-tasking with Hiss Golden Messenger virtual concert playing rn too, but...
Why do you think it isn't fair to figure that Kanye prob made a typo between Teddy/Theo? Very similar usernames that i've confused more than once myself. I don't think it is wise to try and telegraph too much from it, personally
The way you excused him for it rubbed me the wrong way. Obviously it could be a typo, but it might have been a freudian slip as well. I don't know what it was, but the fact that you excused it so quickly made me want to strongly throw out the other possibility.
Rummy 500 just kanyes word salad and where the runoff is currently
Yeah, just finished reading his word salad. My only real takeaway is the thing I just posted. Other than that, it was just a whole lot of speculation tbh. Could be helpful to look back on later if, say, we learn one of his top suspects is actually Mafia, or that he's Inspector, or what have you, but for now, I don't feel like I have much more response to it to add.
I like the idea of an SFA/Potent/someone else runoff. Am currently on Danny myself and think he's a viable candidate to have in there, but if others don't agree, so be it.
Considering you've found the need to respond to my threads as if you are threatened by me I offer you some peace my confused counterpart. May you find peace in your restless soul.
Post by potentpotables on Jul 1, 2020 18:31:18 GMT -5
I might just be bitter because you got to frame it in a positive way, Rummy 500, when I would have asked the question myself or just pointed out a mistake. Obviously you could have pure intentions in doing it the way you did, but I think it bears watching that Kanye said the wrong name, and you let him slide by with it.
Currently trying to sift through all his quoted thoughts. I am admittedly multi-tasking with Hiss Golden Messenger virtual concert playing rn too, but...
Why do you think it isn't fair to figure that Kanye prob made a typo between Teddy/Theo? Very similar usernames that i've confused more than once myself. I don't think it is wise to try and telegraph too much from it, personally
The way you excused him for it rubbed me the wrong way. Obviously it could be a typo, but it might have been a freudian slip as well. I don't know what it was, but the fact that you excused it so quickly made me want to strongly throw out the other possibility.
Are you implying that Theo and I are mafia together and I wanted Theo to fake? And then how would teddy be confirmed doctor? He hasn't said anything about doctors
Last four voters this game, btw - me/SFA/Kanye/Teddy. With all this suspicion on me and SFA this game, I'm surprised this hasn't been mentioned. If it has, I don't recall it.
Ah the classic "throw attention to myself because why would I highlight my own guilt as mafia" tactic
No - it's the "this is usually a proven tactic in getting a mafia person and nobody has used it yet, and if y'all exile me you're going to need as much help as possible" tactic. I understand that you are suspicious of me (for nebulous reasons, but whatever), but it would help if you kept an open mind and considered that your read on me *might* be wrong.
Ah the classic "throw attention to myself because why would I highlight my own guilt as mafia" tactic
No - it's the "this is usually a proven tactic in getting a mafia person and nobody has used it yet, and if y'all exile me you're going to need as much help as possible" tactic. I understand that you are suspicious of me (for nebulous reasons, but whatever), but it would help if you kept an open mind and considered that your read on me *might* be wrong.
The way you excused him for it rubbed me the wrong way. Obviously it could be a typo, but it might have been a freudian slip as well. I don't know what it was, but the fact that you excused it so quickly made me want to strongly throw out the other possibility.
Are you implying that Theo and I are mafia together and I wanted Theo to fake? And then how would teddy be confirmed doctor? He hasn't said anything about doctors
No, and the fact that you twisted this so much makes the obfuscation more interesting. My, I wouldn't even call it a theory, it's not a hunch, it's a thing I noticed, is that you and Teddy could be mafia together, with Theo as the real doctor.
Theo, Kanye, Maddog - 3 without votes after all initial votes are in, though Theo did have a Carini vote first.
Interesting that you pointed out who didn't get voted when it was convenient for you
Why are you mad people didn't bring up the last 4 when you yourself didn't? You even went through the trouble to find out who wasn't voted for.
But of course since you aren't the 3 that didn't get votes it makes sense for you to mention it. And then since you're in the last 4, you let it slip later now that you're in heat to defend yourself
Are you implying that Theo and I are mafia together and I wanted Theo to fake? And then how would teddy be confirmed doctor? He hasn't said anything about doctors
No, and the fact that you twisted this so much makes the obfuscation more interesting. My, I wouldn't even call it a theory, it's not a hunch, it's a thing I noticed, is that you and Teddy could be mafia together, with Theo as the real doctor.
So if teddy and I are mafia together why would I say he's confirmed doc?
No - it's the "this is usually a proven tactic in getting a mafia person and nobody has used it yet, and if y'all exile me you're going to need as much help as possible" tactic. I understand that you are suspicious of me (for nebulous reasons, but whatever), but it would help if you kept an open mind and considered that your read on me *might* be wrong.
Dude I'm not even voting for you lmao
This is disingenuous - I didn't say you were voting for me, I said you were suspicious of me.
No, and the fact that you twisted this so much makes the obfuscation more interesting. My, I wouldn't even call it a theory, it's not a hunch, it's a thing I noticed, is that you and Teddy could be mafia together, with Theo as the real doctor.
So if teddy and I are mafia together why would I say he's confirmed doc?
It's a slip, you wouldn't have done it on purpose. But again, if you read what I said in response to Rummy, I'm fully willing to consider that you made a mistake, it might not be a huge deal. My issue isn't with you, it's with Rummy immediately excusing you when someone instead could have called you on it, gotten your response, and moved on.
So if teddy and I are mafia together why would I say he's confirmed doc?
It's a slip, you wouldn't have done it on purpose. But again, if you read what I said in response to Rummy, I'm fully willing to consider that you made a mistake, it might not be a huge deal. My issue isn't with you, it's with Rummy immediately excusing you when someone instead could have called you on it, gotten your response, and moved on.
So now you're backtracking? I legitimately am just trying to understand what the slip could even mean
I'm also suspicious of SFA. When I was mafia with him he stressed the importance of finding out who inspector was by looking at votes. There wasn't much switching and no super interesting votes in general. I think it makes sense for mafia SFA to not even attempt to try to find inspector since no one really attacked him and also he probably didnt really find anything to grab at.
Then probably Rummy, Maddog, Danbob in that order.
This is all pretty illogical
1. Literally all mafia look for how people vote to find inspector.... but also to narrow down suspects based on timing/known info an inspector would know. To clarify, this doesn't just mean who a suspected inspector voted for. So claiming the exact events of this game could point to me based on something that banal is a pretty bad argument.
2. I have the PM conversation from both our games together saved but I'm pretty sure I can't post screengrabs. But if I remember I've went into pretty fine detail about the actions and words of everyone. It's how we had it narrowed down to a couple of choices in the first game. The second game wasn't as active but we still had the actually inspector in our top suspects. Point being there was much more to us, and me specifically, looking for mafia in those games. To cherry pick one little detail of the paragraphs I wrote in those PMs and use it to tie me to completely unrelated and unknowable events is fairly wrongheaded.
3. The first person we whacked in that first game had like 4 posts. Nothing super interesting he did besides the timing lead us to him. We thought he had your name and he actually voted to help you at one point. So again, it was much more complicated and nuanced than your suggesting in your attempt to tie me to mafia's night decision in a completely unrelated game.
4. "No one really attacked him" could apply to the majority of players. You also present this like mafia isn't a group of 3 people who all would be on the lookout for their name being brought up, etc. How you come to the conclusion that this applies more to me I don't really understand.
Basically this is all grasping at straws and it's frankly kinda suspicious. I've already said the mafia probably didn't have much to go off of. So agree with you there. What I don't agree with is this conspiracy theory logic of working backwards to fit some conclusion you're looking for. Especially when you're talking points apply pretty equally to everyone.
I've got some things going on in my life right now and I just haven't had the time/will to concentrate on this the last couple days. But looking over things I don't really have much suspicion as of yet. I do agree, as I've mentioned, that several players are acting very different. However, I haven't played in a good while so I'm not sure if that's an organic development or not. I've admittedly been pretty lowkey so far as well, so I don't have much room to talk.
After this weird post I feel pretty good just retaliating.
Theo, Kanye, Maddog - 3 without votes after all initial votes are in, though Theo did have a Carini vote first.
Interesting that you pointed out who didn't get voted when it was convenient for you
Why are you mad people didn't bring up the last 4 when you yourself didn't? You even went through the trouble to find out who wasn't voted for.
But of course since you aren't the 3 that didn't get votes it makes sense for you to mention it. And then since you're in the last 4, you let it slip later now that you're in heat to defend yourself
I'm not "mad", it was something I mentioned, to give the town more information. Someone usually mentions it D1; I didn't do that this game, you are correct, and I should have. If you want to exile me due to that, have at it, though I'll note that you'll note you aren't even voting for me right now.
I'm also suspicious of SFA. When I was mafia with him he stressed the importance of finding out who inspector was by looking at votes. There wasn't much switching and no super interesting votes in general. I think it makes sense for mafia SFA to not even attempt to try to find inspector since no one really attacked him and also he probably didnt really find anything to grab at.
Then probably Rummy, Maddog, Danbob in that order.
This is all pretty illogical
1. Literally all mafia look for how people vote to find inspector.... but also to narrow down suspects based on timing/known info an inspector would know. To clarify, this doesn't just mean who a suspected inspector voted for. So claiming the exact events of this game could point to me based on something that banal is a pretty bad argument.
2. I have the PM conversation from both our games together saved but I'm pretty sure I can't post screengrabs. But if I remember I've went into pretty fine detail about the actions and words of everyone. It's how we had it narrowed down to a couple of choices in the first game. The second game wasn't as active but we still had the actually inspector in our top suspects. Point being there was much more to us, and me specifically, looking for mafia in those games. To cherry pick one little detail of the paragraphs I wrote in those PMs and use it to tie me to completely unrelated and unknowable events is fairly wrongheaded.
3. The first person we whacked in that first game had like 4 posts. Nothing super interesting he did besides the timing lead us to him. We thought he had your name and he actually voted to help you at one point. So again, it was much more complicated and nuanced than your suggesting in your attempt to tie me to mafia's night decision in a completely unrelated game.
4. "No one really attacked him" could apply to the majority of players. You also present this like mafia isn't a group of 3 people who all would be on the lookout for their name being brought up, etc. How you come to the conclusion that this applies more to me I don't really understand.
Basically this is all grasping at straws and it's frankly kinda suspicious. I've already said the mafia probably didn't have much to go off of. So agree with you there. What I don't agree with is this conspiracy theory logic of working backwards to fit some conclusion you're looking for. Especially when you're talking points apply pretty equally to everyone.
I've got some things going on in my life right now and I just haven't had the time/will to concentrate on this the last couple days. But looking over things I don't really have much suspicion as of yet. I do agree, as I've mentioned, that several players are acting very different. However, I haven't played in a good while so I'm not sure if that's an organic development or not. I've admittedly been pretty lowkey so far as well, so I don't have much room to talk.
After this weird post I feel pretty good just retaliating.
SFA >>> Kanye (Silver Surfer)
This is a response I think brings the game to a higher level. I genuinely think this is a very good response to my suspicions of you and understand why you'd vote for me, but I am town
