Mafia 176 Spring Cleanin' Yo Azz

Your post completely affirms what I’m saying though: he can (and does) post shit like that regardless of role. You’re right, there was a time he did that and he was maf. All I’m saying here is that he could easily be doing that same shit whole town. It is fine for you to be sus of him for it but I’m also allowed to not be

Extension request

the fact that you're calling Dan a flip flopper.... pot, kettle. you were on and on about dan earlier/yesterday. you had this whole long post with possible trios and they pretty much all included dan (which i dont agree with, but you and samp both seem to think dan is maf)

and speaking of which - what happened to your samp suspicions? you just wanted to throw out your teammate's name enough for it to float around but then not actually vote for him?

so whats your thinking: me/dan/samp? how does that trio make any sense?

Day 3 Round 1

Tally
Pink-2-(Rummy*,Market)
Rummy-2(Pink, Farris)
Dan-1(Samp)


Record
Pink>Rummy
Dan>Rummy>Null
Rummy>Pink*
Market>Pink
Samp>Dan
Farris>Rummy

*Denotes locked vote for this round.

History


Left to Vote
Dan808
durkle

Pinkstickynote has missed one vote.


Round ends at 4pm 4/3 unless everyone locks. I’ll be traveling tomorrow, so giving a lil extra space and time.

chummy aka not thinking your maf and therefore not being in accordance with those who do think you are? i'll be sure to ignore my gut/logic in future to condemn you as you'd prefer xo

i doubt you'll change your mind here so im not going to give you huge WORD SALAD as you complained of from me in D2 (even though you and i both know well im extremely prone to doing when townie wrongly accused, or in this case full-on framed), but i do need to correct you on an inaccurate claim of what i've done/said.

i felt confident that MD was most likely inspo by end of D2, post fake, because there hadnt been a counter - which would've been more likely to occur than not D2 if inspector was still alive then. you know this. because a delayed counter, all the way into the next Day, is a SUPER hard sell even if that counter is the true inspector. the onlyyyy scenario i saw that could make sense for an inspector not coming out to counter the fake was if they had pink's name and nothing else. from my perspective, it just was in every way possible way more likely MD was inspector, with the information i had by that point and how things played out. if you;d been in my shoes, i think you'd have felt the same way.

but as you'll see in my reread analysis unless you skipped over that, i saw multiple routes that mafia could've been working from when they decided to fake, ones that didnt all comprise "MD must be inspector." i think they definitely could've gone into the fake with the idea that it was either 1) MD, 2) cum with pink's name OR 3) me with pink's name - the latter two of which they would've known would be hard for either me or cum if inspo to not look super sus in countering with. i have repeatedly stated in D3 that maf wasn't necessarily iron clad in confidence that MD was inspo when they faked. i explain this thoroughly and you're ignoring it.

at the time of the fake, though, as the one being framed of course my initial thought when there wasnt a counter was, "guess MD was inspector" and certainly now in D3 with no counter at all. tell me what you would've thought in my shoes instead?

You weren’t saying “it was likely” by the end of day 2. You said you thought he was inspector even before pinks fake.

Quite the change of tune from the top of this page where you said rummy pink was the best runoff

i said either MD or cum. and then with a reread, saw it could've been also that they considered me with pink's name so faking with my name would've put me in a shit position.

is it really that odd for a townie to have leanings towards 2 or 3 potential people being inspo once into the thick of d2? i wasn't talking about it in thread carelessly, and certainly there are games where im town and have no fucking clue who i feel could be inspo d2 or even d3 if they havent come out, but this isnt an anomaly where i have thoughts between a couple folks by mid-d2. once pink came out, my feelings on it strengthened.

stop trying to make this more sus than it actually is.

Yes we only have until 4pm and I want to hear what Durkle has to say. What's so complicated about that? I never said I was less suspicious of you Rummy. 

Yes it’s extremely odd

you never do this as townie? like quietly/internally without stating it in thread? i call cap on that.

it's odd/sus when people are writing in thread "ooh i think ____ is inspo" pre reveal, but to claim that you never have leanings on it as town is ridiculous. we've even talked about this out of game before, dude.

pink faked d2, stayed alive n2, came back and claimed he had info only on the JUST WHACKED person, again. then mostly disappeared except to pop in with one or two pretty lazy posts in the past few days.

ive been engaging directly and trying to fucking get this right for town, and apparently im just being "too chill" about it

Yes I think as d2 progressed there is in no truly identifiable way to be as worried MD was inspector as you claimed to be unless you knew who the other mafia were.

yeah im just frustrated rn because it is fine that dan wants to vote me and he thinks i should be the one to go here blah blah, but apparently im not allowed to have had a hunch about something d2 just because he didn't? make that make sense to me.